Skip to main content

The woman who took the throne in June 1762 had not a drop of Romanov blood. Sophie of Anhalt-Zerbst was born in Stettin, a Prussian port, in 1729, the daughter of a minor German prince serving as a Prussian general. She came to Russia at fourteen as the chosen bride of the future Peter III, converted to Orthodoxy as Ekaterina Alekseyevna, and married him in 1745. The marriage was unhappy. She read Voltaire, Montesquieu and Tacitus, learned Russian well and built friendships among the guards. At thirty-three she seized power with the help of the Orlov brothers. Lacking a hereditary claim, she had to earn her legitimacy by results.

Church land and the economy

Peter III had begun to take church estates, and Catherine at first seemed to reverse him to win clerical support. In 1764 she went further than he had. She took the church lands into the hands of the state, together with roughly a million male peasants who lived on them, and placed the clergy on salaries. Metropolitan Arseny of Rostov protested and was defrocked and imprisoned for life. In 1765 Catherine sponsored the Free Economic Society, which soon held an open essay contest on whether peasants should own property.

The Instruction and the Commission

Catherine spent two years writing her Nakaz, or Instruction, for a commission to codify Russian law. It borrowed so freely from Montesquieu that she joked to Frederick II about having plundered him. Following the Italian jurist Cesare Beccaria, it condemned torture and argued that punishment should prevent crime rather than take revenge. Yet it also argued that a country as vast as Russia needed an autocrat.

The Legislative Commission opened in Moscow in July 1767 with more than five hundred deputies chosen by nobles, towns, state peasants, Cossacks and non-Russian peoples, who brought written instructions from their electors. Serfs on private estates had no deputies, though they were about half the population. Debates on noble privilege and serfdom were sharp and inconclusive. When war with the Ottoman Empire began, the full commission was adjourned in December 1768 and never met again.

In 1768 Catherine also had herself and her son Paul inoculated against smallpox by the English doctor Thomas Dimsdale, setting an example for the nobility. But in the countryside the trend ran the other way. Landlords had gained the right to send serfs to Siberia and, from 1765, to hard labor. A decree of August 1767 forbade serfs to petition the empress against their masters, on pain of the knout and exile. When the landowner Darya Saltykova was convicted in 1768 of torturing dozens of her serfs to death, the case was treated as monstrous, but the system that let her act for years was left in place.

Pugachev

In 1773 Emelian Pugachev, a Don Cossack and army deserter, appeared among the Yaik Cossacks east of the Volga claiming to be the dead emperor Peter III, miraculously saved. He was one of many pretenders in these years, but his timing was right. The Yaik Cossacks resented the loss of their old freedoms. The Bashkirs, led by the poet and warrior Salavat Yulayev, defended their lands against settlers and ironworks. Serfs bound to the Ural factories hated their labor, and Old Believers welcomed a tsar who promised the old faith.

The rebels besieged Orenburg through the winter of 1773 to 1774, took and burned much of Kazan in July 1774 and then swept down the Volga, where peasants rose and killed landlords and priests. Government armies finally broke the rebellion, and Pugachev was betrayed by his own Cossacks in September 1774. He was taken to Moscow in a cage and executed in January 1775. To erase the memory, Catherine had the Yaik River renamed the Ural, and the Yaik Cossacks became the Ural Cossacks.

Her answer to the revolt was to strengthen local government. The Provincial Reform of 1775 divided Russia into more, smaller provinces, each with roughly three to four hundred thousand inhabitants, and set up courts, police and welfare boards, many of them staffed by locally elected nobles. Ten years later the Charter to the Nobility confirmed noble privileges, as the next level shows.

Worked example: Pugachev's manifesto of July 1774

At the height of the Volga rising Pugachev issued a manifesto in the name of Emperor Peter III. It granted the people freedom, the cross and the beard, which meant the old faith, and lands, forests, meadows and fisheries. It freed them from the poll tax and the recruit levy, and it called on them to seize and punish the nobles who had oppressed them.

Read it closely. The rebels did not call for an end to monarchy. They called for a true tsar who would defend his people against the nobles in between, a belief historians call naive monarchism. Then ask who the rebels were. Soviet historians called the revolt a peasant war. Others stress the Cossack core and the grievances of Bashkirs and other non-Russian peoples, whose aims were land and autonomy rather than the end of serfdom. The best reading is that the uprising was a coalition of groups with different grievances, held together by a name. Each could see in "Peter III" the ruler it needed.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Where was Catherine II born?
2. What did Catherine do with church lands in 1764?
3. Which group had no deputies in the Legislative Commission of 1767?
4. Which writer did the Nakaz follow in condemning torture?
5. What did the decree of August 1767 forbid?
6. Whom did Pugachev claim to be?
7. What happened to the Yaik River after the revolt?
8. What did the Provincial Reform of 1775 do?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia