In late April 1682 Tsar Fyodor III died in Moscow, aged twenty, without a son. Two half-brothers could follow him. Ivan, fifteen, was the son of Tsar Alexei's first wife, Maria Miloslavskaya. He was frail and had poor eyesight. Peter was the son of Alexei's second wife, Natalya Naryshkina, and he was tall, healthy and restless. The patriarch and a crowd gathered in the Kremlin proclaimed Peter tsar, though he was nine years old, not quite ten. The relatives of the first wife, the Miloslavskys, had no intention of accepting that. (Dates here follow the Julian calendar that Russians used, which ran ten days behind western Europe in the 1600s and eleven days behind in the 1700s.)
The Muscovite state
The tsar of Muscovy was an autocrat, crowned and anointed, answerable to God alone. In practice he governed with a council of great families, the boyar duma, and through dozens of prikazy, government offices that each handled a set piece of business, such as foreign envoys, musketeers, Siberia or postal horses. Elite women lived in seclusion in separate quarters called the terem and rarely appeared in public.
Most people were peasants, and a growing share of them were serfs. The great Law Code of 1649, the Ulozhenie, removed the time limit on recovering runaway peasants. After it, a serf and his descendants belonged to the estate for good.
The church was split as well. In the 1650s Patriarch Nikon brought Russian rites into line with Greek practice. Among other changes, believers were told to cross themselves with three fingers in place of two. Those who refused, the Old Believers, saw the reforms as a betrayal of true faith. Their most famous leader, the priest Avvakum, was burned at Pustozersk in the far north in April 1682, only weeks before the crisis in Moscow.
The Streltsy rising
Moscow was guarded by the streltsy, hereditary musketeer regiments whose men lived with their families in their own districts. They had long complained of unpaid wages and abusive colonels. On 15 May 1682 a rumor spread that the Naryshkins had strangled Ivan. Historians believe the Miloslavsky faction helped spread it. Armed streltsy stormed the Kremlin. Natalya brought both boys out onto the Red Staircase to show that Ivan was alive, but the soldiers still seized her adviser Artamon Matveyev and threw him onto their pikes. Over three days they killed two of her brothers and other officials. Peter saw much of it.
A double throne
The settlement that followed was unusual. Ivan V and Peter I would rule together as co-tsars, and their elder sister Sophia would act as regent. A double throne was made for the coronation in June 1682. Sophia, aged twenty-four, governed in fact for seven years. Her leading minister was Prince Vasily Golitsyn, a cultivated man who read Latin and talked of reform. Russia joined the Holy League against the Ottoman Empire, and Golitsyn led two huge armies toward the Crimean Khanate, in 1687 and 1689. Both campaigns failed without taking Crimea, defeated by heat, steppe fires and lack of water as much as by the Tatars.
The boy at Preobrazhenskoe
Peter lived mostly at Preobrazhenskoe, a royal village outside Moscow. His formal schooling was thin, but he learned by doing. He gathered boys and young men into play regiments that grew into real ones: the Preobrazhensky and Semyonovsky regiments, named after villages near Moscow, which became the elite guards of the empire. In a storehouse he found an old English sailing boat, and a Dutchman taught him to sail it. He spent long hours in the Foreign Quarter, where Protestant and Catholic officers, merchants and craftsmen lived. There he befriended the Scottish general Patrick Gordon and the Genevan adventurer Franz Lefort. In January 1689, aged sixteen, he was married to Evdokia Lopukhina.
Worked example: the crisis of August 1689
By the summer of 1689 Peter was seventeen, married and no longer a child, and Sophia's regency had lost its justification. On the night of 7 to 8 August he was woken with a warning that streltsy were coming to kill him. He rode in haste to the Trinity Monastery of St Sergius, some seventy kilometers northeast of Moscow.
What happened next shows how power worked. There was no battle. Each side called on the leading men of the state to come to it. The patriarch went to Trinity. So did foreign officers under Patrick Gordon, boyars and, one by one, colonels of the streltsy. Sophia's support melted. Fyodor Shaklovity, the head of the musketeers' office and her closest ally, was handed over and executed. Golitsyn was exiled to the far north. Sophia was confined in the Novodevichy Convent on the edge of Moscow.
Notice what decided the contest: not law or a vote but the loyalty of soldiers and great families near the throne. Peter left government to his mother's relatives for some years, and Ivan remained co-tsar in name until his death in 1696. The pattern of 1682 and 1689, in which armed men in the capital and family factions decided who ruled, would return again and again in the century ahead.
