Skip to main content

An emperor with something to prove

The Yongzheng emperor came to the throne in December 1722 at the age of 44, after years of watching his brothers scheme for the succession. He reigned only thirteen years, until 1735, but he was perhaps the hardest working ruler China ever had. He rose before dawn, read reports late into the night and covered them with comments. Because rumors questioned his right to rule, he spent much of his reign showing that he deserved it.

He also made sure no succession struggle would happen again. He wrote his heir's name and placed it in a sealed box behind a plaque reading "Upright and Bright" in the Qianqing Palace, with a copy kept on his person. Only at his death would the box be opened. The secret succession system lasted for most of the dynasty and spared it the open feuds of Kangxi's last years.

Government by memorial

Officials had long sent formal reports, called memorials, through the regular bureaucracy, where many eyes saw them. Kangxi began allowing trusted men to send private reports straight to him. Yongzheng turned this into a system. Palace memorials were sealed reports sent directly to the emperor, bypassing the ministries. He answered them in vermilion ink, scolding, praising, joking and demanding facts, and the memorials came back to him to be stored.

Around 1729, during a war against the Dzungars, Yongzheng set up a small office to handle military supply and secret correspondence. It grew into the Grand Council, which began as an office for wartime finance and secrecy and became the inner core of Qing government. The historian Beatrice Bartlett has shown that it took shape gradually and only became a formal institution under the next emperor, which is a reminder that big institutions often begin as temporary fixes.

Fixing the money

Kangxi's frozen quotas left local government starved of funds. Magistrates filled the gap with an informal surcharge called the meltage fee, a charge said to cover silver lost when small payments were melted into ingots. In practice it varied wildly, fed corruption and paid for gifts to superiors.

From 1724 Yongzheng's reform brought the meltage fee into official accounts at a fixed rate. The money went to the provincial treasury and paid for local public costs and for new allowances called "silver to nourish honesty," supplements meant to let officials live without taking bribes. He also folded the head tax into the land tax, so that the burden fell more on those who owned land.

Freeing the "mean people"

Chinese law ranked certain hereditary groups as debased: they could not sit the examinations, buy land freely or marry commoners. Between 1723 and the early 1730s Yongzheng issued edicts for several of them, beginning with hereditary musician households in Shanxi and Shaanxi, many descended from families punished in the early Ming, and extending to the "fallen people" of Zhejiang and the Tanka boat people of Guangdong. The edicts registered them as commoners, ending their hereditary debased status in law. Prejudice survived on the ground for generations, but the principle that birth alone should not condemn a family was written into law.

Treason by the book

In 1728 a Hunan schoolteacher named Zeng Jing, inspired by the anti-Manchu writings of an earlier scholar, sent a student to urge a provincial governor-general to rebel. The official reported the plot at once. Instead of simply executing Zeng, Yongzheng interrogated him at length, won his repentance and published the exchanges in a book. The Record of Great Righteousness Resolving Confusion argued that the right to rule came from virtue, not ethnic origin. The dead scholar whose writings had inspired Zeng was exhumed and his family punished.

When Yongzheng died in 1735, his son took a different view. The new emperor recalled the book and had Zeng Jing executed, judging it unwise to keep the accusations in circulation even alongside their rebuttal.

Worked example: one county's meltage fee

Here is an illustrative county, with round numbers, to show what the reform changed. Suppose its land tax quota is 20,000 taels. Before the reform the magistrate collects a surcharge of 15 percent, or 3,000 taels. No one above him knows exactly how it is spent. Some pays clerks and runners, some buys gifts for the prefect and governor, some stays in his pocket.

After the reform the surcharge is fixed at 10 percent, or 2,000 taels, and sent openly to the provincial treasury. From it the magistrate receives 1,000 taels as his nourish honesty allowance and 600 taels for approved office costs, and 400 taels go toward paying off old provincial deficits. That accounts for all 2,000 taels. Taxpayers pay less, the money can be tracked, and the official has a legal income.

The historian Madeleine Zelin, who studied the reform closely, found that it worked for a time but eroded later in the century. Rates stayed fixed while prices and duties grew, and new informal fees crept back in. The lesson is not that reform is useless, but that a fix built for one decade needs adjusting in the next.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Where did Yongzheng hide the name of his chosen heir?
2. What were palace memorials under Yongzheng?
3. How did the Grand Council begin?
4. What did Yongzheng's meltage reform do?
5. What was the silver to nourish honesty?
6. What did Yongzheng's edicts do for groups such as hereditary musician households?
7. What did the Record of Great Righteousness Resolving Confusion argue?
8. What did Yongzheng's successor do with the Record of Great Righteousness?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia