Skip to main content

Around 1900 a new mood spread among middle-class Americans: a belief that the problems of industrial society could be studied, exposed and fixed. Historians call the people who acted on that belief progressives. They were never one movement. They included Protestant ministers and socialist organizers, business leaders and union women, engineers, social workers and suffragists. What they shared was a conviction that the old faith in individual effort and limited government no longer fit a world of giant corporations and crowded cities.

The muckrakers

Cheap, mass-circulation magazines gave reformers a national audience. The January 1903 issue of McClure's Magazine carried investigations by Ida Tarbell, Lincoln Steffens and Ray Stannard Baker, and is often seen as the moment investigative journalism came of age. Tarbell's History of the Standard Oil Company, published as a book in 1904, documented Rockefeller's methods with careful use of court records and testimony. Her own father had been an independent oil producer hurt by Rockefeller's rebate deals. Steffens's articles, collected as The Shame of the Cities, showed how business interests and city bosses together corrupted government.

Theodore Roosevelt admired some of this work but disliked its tone. In 1906 he compared the journalists to a character in John Bunyan's Pilgrim's Progress who could look only downward at filth. He coined the name muckrakers, saying they were "often indispensable to the well-being of society; but only if they know when to stop raking the muck." The writers adopted the label with pride.

Rewriting the rules of democracy

Many progressives believed that bosses and corporations ruled because ordinary voters had too little direct power, so they changed the machinery of elections. States adopted the secret ballot, printed by the government and marked in private, during the late 1880s and 1890s. South Dakota in 1898 was the first state to adopt the initiative and referendum, letting citizens propose laws and vote on them directly. Oregon adopted them in 1902, and the package of direct democracy became known as the Oregon System. Many states added the recall, which lets voters remove an official before the end of a term.

In Wisconsin, Governor Robert La Follette fought railroads and party bosses. In 1903 Wisconsin adopted the first statewide direct primary, so that voters rather than party conventions chose nominees. La Follette also drew experts from the state university to draft laws and staff commissions, a partnership known as the Wisconsin Idea. Cities, meanwhile, experimented with new forms of government, including the city manager, a trained administrator hired by an elected council to run services like a business. Staunton, Virginia, hired one of the first in 1908, and Dayton, Ohio, became the first large city to adopt the plan, in 1914, after a devastating flood.

Labor, women and the courts

Reformers also targeted working conditions, and here they ran into the courts. In Lochner v. New York (1905) the Supreme Court struck down a law limiting bakers to ten hours a day, as a violation of freedom of contract. Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. dissented, writing that "the Fourteenth Amendment does not enact Mr. Herbert Spencer's Social Statics," a sharp reminder that the majority was reading one economic philosophy into the Constitution.

Three years later the reformers found a way around the obstacle. Florence Kelley of the National Consumers League and her colleague Josephine Goldmark helped the lawyer Louis Brandeis prepare a brief of more than a hundred pages, most of it evidence from doctors and factory inspectors. In Muller v. Oregon (1908) the Court upheld a ten-hour limit for women workers, persuaded by this mass of social facts. The "Brandeis brief" became a model for using research in court. Yet the ruling rested on the claim that women were weaker and needed protection, reasoning that later feminists saw as a trap that limited women's choices.

Worked example: the Triangle fire

On the afternoon of 25 March 1911, a fire broke out on the eighth floor of the Asch Building in New York, where the Triangle Waist Company employed hundreds of young immigrant women, mostly Jewish and Italian, sewing blouses. The flames spread through piles of fabric scraps. One stairway door on the ninth floor was locked, reportedly to prevent theft. The single fire escape collapsed, and fire ladders reached only to the sixth floor. Crowds below watched workers jump to their deaths. The Triangle fire killed 146 people. The owners were tried for manslaughter and acquitted.

The response shows how progressive reform worked. Unions and settlement workers organized mass protests and a funeral march. New York created a Factory Investigating Commission, whose investigators included Frances Perkins, a social worker who had watched the fire from the street. Led by two Tammany Hall legislators, Robert Wagner and Al Smith, the commission toured factories across the state, and the legislature passed dozens of laws on fire safety, sanitation and working hours. Exposure created outrage, outrage created a public body, and the body gathered facts that turned into law. Even machine politicians, once the target of reform, learned to champion it when their immigrant voters demanded it.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Which magazine's January 1903 issue carried work by Tarbell, Steffens and Baker?
2. What did Ida Tarbell's book of 1904 document?
3. What did Roosevelt say about the journalists he called muckrakers?
4. Which state first adopted the initiative and referendum, in 1898?
5. Which state adopted the first statewide direct primary, in 1903?
6. What was the Wisconsin Idea?
7. Why did the Supreme Court strike down a ten-hour law for bakers in 1905?
8. What did the Court uphold in Muller v. Oregon (1908)?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia