For the pragmatists, democracy was more than voting. If ideas are tested by their consequences, and if inquiry works best when many people with different experiences can challenge each other, then a free society looks like a large, ongoing experiment.
Jane Addams and sympathetic knowledge
Jane Addams (1860 to 1935) is usually remembered as a reformer, but she was also a serious thinker whom Dewey regarded as a teacher. Dewey served on the board of her settlement house, Hull House, and lectured there often. In Democracy and Social Ethics (1902), Addams argued that personal goodness is not enough in a complex industrial society. A wealthy woman can be kind to her own servants while ignoring the conditions that make whole classes poor. Real social ethics, Addams wrote, is not reached "by travelling a sequestered byway, but by mixing on the thronged and common road where all must turn out for one another, and at least see the size of one another's burdens."
Behind this lay a method that scholars now call sympathetic knowledge: understanding others by living and working alongside them, not by judging from a distance. Addams thought charity workers often failed because they measured the poor by middle-class standards and missed the logic of their lives.
She applied the same method to conflict. During the bitter Pullman railway strike of 1894, Addams wrote an essay comparing the company's owner, George Pullman, to King Lear. In "A Modern Lear" she argued that Pullman, like Lear, had demanded gratitude while refusing to see things from the point of view of those he believed he was benefiting. She criticized the workers' side too, but her main point was that a benefactor who cannot imagine the other side's experience will be baffled by their anger. The essay was too pointed for editors at first and appeared only in 1912.
Mead and the social self
George Herbert Mead (1863 to 1931), Dewey's friend and colleague at Chicago, gave pragmatism a theory of the self. Mead argued that we become selves only through communication, by learning to see ourselves from others' points of view. He also worked on Chicago reform committees, supported striking garment workers and championed immigrant education. Mead published no book in his lifetime; Mind, Self and Society (1934) was assembled after his death, largely from students' notes. For Mead the capacity to take others' perspectives was also the root of democratic life: a citizen who can imagine how a policy looks to others is better able to deliberate with them.
Dewey's public
Dewey's political writing tied these strands together. In Democracy and Education (1916) he treated democracy as a form of shared living, and he returned to the theme in The Public and Its Problems (1927). There Dewey defined a public as all those affected by the indirect consequences of transactions, to such an extent that it seems necessary to have those consequences systematically cared for. When a factory's smoke drifts over a town, the people who breathe it form a public, whether they know it or not. The trouble in modern society, Dewey argued, is that such publics are scattered and cannot easily find and recognize themselves.
In a 1939 essay, "Creative Democracy: The Task Before Us," written as he turned eighty, Dewey said democracy is above all a personal way of life: a habit of meeting others through cooperation and inquiry instead of force, and of treating disagreements as chances to learn. That ideal sits close to the belief in equal human worth: each person's experience counts as evidence about how shared life is going.
Critics and a war
Pragmatist politics had sharp critics. When Dewey supported American entry into the First World War, his former admirer Randolph Bourne wrote a bitter essay, "Twilight of Idols" (1917). Bourne charged that pragmatism's focus on technique and adjustment left it without values strong enough to resist the war; intelligence had become a tool for whatever ends were already in power. Addams, by contrast, opposed the war and was widely attacked for it. The cultural critic Lewis Mumford later described pragmatism as a philosophy of acquiescence to industrial society. Dewey's defenders answer that his method demands constant criticism of ends, and that he himself spent decades criticizing business power, segregated schooling and censorship.
Worked example: a factory on the river
A food processing plant opens upstream of a small town. Within a year, people who fish downstream notice fewer catches, and a school near the river reports odd smells on warm days. Nobody in town signed a contract with the plant, but they are affected by its indirect consequences. In Dewey's terms, a public has formed, though it does not yet know itself.
Its first problem is to find itself: residents compare notes, a teacher maps the complaints, a fishing club joins with parents. Addams would add that someone must actually talk with the plant's workers, many of whom live in town and fear for their jobs, rather than casting them as villains. Mead's point about taking the role of others helps here: the plant's managers, asked to imagine a summer afternoon at the school, may see the problem differently. The process ends in a public meeting, monitoring and a revised discharge plan, which are tested in turn.
