Skip to main content

About 3,300 years ago a new kind of pottery appeared on the islands east of New Guinea. Within a few centuries, the people who made it had sailed farther than any humans before them, into islands no one had ever seen. Their story begins with a language family.

A family of languages

The Austronesian languages, around 1,200 of them, are spoken from Madagascar off Africa to Rapa Nui off South America. To find a language family's homeland, they look for the place where its branches are most varied, because that is where the language has had the longest time to split. Most of the main branches of Austronesian are found only on Taiwan, which marks the island as the family's likely homeland. All the other Austronesian languages, from the Philippines to Hawaii, form just one branch.

Archaeology fits. Farming villages with rice, millet and pottery appear on Taiwan by about 3000 BCE, and similar sites appear in the northern Philippines a thousand years later. From there, the trail spreads south and east through the islands of Southeast Asia.

Lapita

The trail becomes clearest in the Bismarck Archipelago, northeast of New Guinea. Lapita pottery is named after a site in New Caledonia excavated in 1952, but its earliest examples come from the Bismarcks, around 3,300 years ago. The pots are decorated with dentate stamping, patterns pressed into wet clay with a comb-like tool, forming bands, geometric designs and sometimes stylized faces.

Then came the leap. Within a few centuries, Lapita sites appear in Vanuatu, New Caledonia, Fiji, Tonga and Samoa. The Lapita people were the first humans to reach Remote Oceania, and by about 2,800 years ago they had settled Tonga and Samoa, on the western edge of what would become Polynesia. The crossing from Vanuatu to Fiji alone is about 800 kilometers of open sea.

They brought a whole way of life in their canoes: pigs, dogs and chickens, the Pacific rat, and crops such as taro, yams and breadfruit, which had to be carried as cuttings because many do not grow from seed. They also kept in touch with home. Obsidian from New Britain, in the Bismarcks, turns up at Lapita sites thousands of kilometers away, showing that the voyagers maintained long-distance exchange.

Express train or tangled web?

How did Austronesian speakers from Taiwan become the Lapita people? Two broad models have competed. The "express train" model, named by Jared Diamond in 1988, pictured a fast migration from Taiwan with little mixing along the way. Its rivals stressed contact. In Roger Green's "Triple I" model, Lapita culture formed through intrusion, innovation and integration: newcomers met long-settled Papuan-speaking peoples of the Bismarcks, borrowed from them and created something new. Supporters of mixing pointed to the fact that many Lapita crops, such as taro and bananas, came from New Guinea, not Asia.

The cemetery at Teouma

In 2003 a bulldozer on the island of Efate, in Vanuatu, exposed a Lapita cemetery about 3,000 years old. Many of the dead at Teouma had been buried and then had their skulls removed, sometimes placed with other bones or in pots. Ancient DNA from these burials, published in 2016, surprised many researchers. The earliest people at Teouma and in Tonga had almost no Papuan ancestry; their ancestry was overwhelmingly East Asian. That suggests the first colonists of Remote Oceania had mixed very little with New Guinea's peoples. Later studies found that within a few centuries, people with Papuan ancestry moved into Vanuatu and largely replaced the first settlers' genes, while the language stayed Austronesian.

So both camps were partly right. The first voyagers into Remote Oceania were close to the express train picture in their genes, yet their culture, crops and pottery had already borrowed heavily from the Bismarcks.

The long pause

Then the voyaging stopped. After reaching Tonga and Samoa, people stayed in western Polynesia for well over a thousand years before sailing farther east. Archaeologists call this the long pause. In that time a distinct Ancestral Polynesian culture took shape. Pottery making faded out and then stopped altogether, and the Polynesian languages emerged as their own branch. Why the pause happened is unclear. Possible answers include the long distances to the next islands, changes in prevailing winds, and the time needed to develop better canoes.

Worked example: genes, words and pots in Vanuatu

Imagine you must answer a simple question: who were the ancestors of the people of Vanuatu today? Three kinds of evidence give three answers.

Language says Austronesian, since nearly all of Vanuatu's more than one hundred languages belong to that family. Pottery says Lapita, a culture already blended from Asian and Bismarck elements. Ancient DNA says the first settlers were mainly of East Asian descent, but that most of the ancestry of living ni-Vanuatu comes from later Papuan-related newcomers.

None of these answers is wrong. Languages, artifacts and genes can travel separately. A people can adopt a language from neighbors, a culture can borrow designs and crops, and newcomers can join a community without replacing its speech. The lesson reaches far beyond the Pacific: no single kind of evidence tells you who someone's ancestors "really" were, and identity has never been a simple matter of blood.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Why do linguists think Taiwan is the Austronesian homeland?
2. What is dentate stamping?
3. What made the Lapita people historically significant?
4. What do finds of New Britain obsidian at distant Lapita sites show?
5. What did the express train model propose?
6. What did Roger Green's Triple I model stress?
7. What did ancient DNA from Teouma reveal?
8. What was the long pause?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia