Skip to main content

When Nietzsche died in 1900 he was becoming famous across Europe. His reputation over the next half century was shaped less by him than by the woman who controlled his papers.

Elisabeth and the archive

His sister Elisabeth married Bernhard Förster in 1885. Förster was a leading antisemitic agitator, and in 1886 the couple sailed to South America, where the next year they founded Nueva Germania, a colony in Paraguay meant to keep German blood pure. Nietzsche despised the venture. In a draft letter to his sister late in 1887 he wrote that her ties to an antisemitic leader expressed a way of life foreign to his own, and that it filled him again and again with anger or sadness. The colony failed, and Förster killed himself in 1889.

Elisabeth returned to Germany and, as her brother sank deeper into illness, took control of his manuscripts and copyrights. She founded the Nietzsche Archive in 1894 and moved it to Weimar in 1897. She wrote his biography, decided which notes were published and how, and assembled The Will to Power from his notebooks, first in 1901 and then in a much larger edition in 1906, presenting it as his crowning work. Later scholars found that she had altered or forged letters to make herself look like his closest confidante.

The Nazi appropriation

In the 1930s Elisabeth welcomed the Nazis. Hitler visited the archive more than once, she is reported to have given him her brother's walking stick, and he attended her funeral in 1935. Nazi academics such as Alfred Baeumler presented Nietzsche as the philosopher of the new Germany, quoting phrases like "will to power," "overman" and "blond beast." Benito Mussolini had written admiringly about him as early as 1908, and Italian Fascists claimed him as well.

The fit was poor. Nietzsche repeatedly mocked German nationalism and condemned antisemitism. He sneered at the slogan "Deutschland, Deutschland über alles," praised the Jews in Beyond Good and Evil as a strong and tenacious people, and suggested it might be useful to expel the antisemitic screamers from the country. His "blond beast" was a predatory lion, an image he applied to noble conquerors of many peoples and eras: Roman, Arab, Germanic and Japanese nobles, Homeric heroes and Scandinavian Vikings alike. In one of his last deranged notes he wrote that he was having all antisemites shot.

Honesty requires adding that the misuse found real handholds. Nietzsche despised democracy and equal rights, spoke of breeding higher types and wrote harsh lines about the sick and the weak. A reader can reject the Nazi reading as a distortion without pretending that his politics were gentle.

Recovery

After the war his reputation was rebuilt. In 1950 the German-American scholar Walter Kaufmann published an influential book presenting him as a humane psychologist and critic rather than a proto-Nazi. Karl Schlechta exposed many of Elisabeth's forgeries in the 1950s, and from 1967 the Italian scholars Giorgio Colli and Mazzino Montinari published a complete critical edition based on the manuscripts themselves, now the standard text. Kaufmann's translations of the major books introduced generations of English readers to a Nietzsche very different from the wartime caricature, though some later scholars felt he had made his subject too tame.

Legacy and critics

His influence is vast and contradictory. Sigmund Freud, Max Weber, Thomas Mann, Rainer Maria Rilke, Albert Camus, Jean-Paul Sartre, Michel Foucault and Gilles Deleuze all took something from him: a suspicion of hidden motives, a sense of values as human creations, a demand to live without false consolation. Psychologists credit him with anticipating ideas about repression and self-deception, and social critics still borrow his account of ressentiment to explain the politics of grievance.

His critics are just as weighty. Bertrand Russell, in a history of philosophy published in 1945, treated him as a prophet of power and imagined the Buddha answering him. Others pressed a deeper charge. The philosopher Philippa Foot argued that Nietzsche's attack on morality is a serious challenge that moral philosophers had largely failed to face, and she later answered it by arguing that justice and kindness serve human flourishing in ways he underrated. For anyone committed to the equal worth of every person, Nietzsche is perhaps the hardest opponent: not a careless enemy of dignity but a brilliant one, who forces its defenders to explain why equal worth holds when people are so plainly unequal in their gifts.

Worked example: a quote on a poster

A gym poster shows a muscular figure under the words "What does not kill me makes me stronger," credited to Nietzsche. The line is genuine: it comes from the "Maxims and Arrows" that open Twilight of the Idols. But context changes it. Nietzsche wrote it while chronically ill and nearly blind, about surviving suffering and turning it into growth, not about physical dominance. Elsewhere he warned that whoever fights monsters should take care not to become a monster. Reading a Nietzsche quotation well means asking where it came from, who has repeated it and why, and what else he said nearby. That habit is itself very Nietzschean, and it is the best protection against the next misuse.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Who was Bernhard Förster, Elisabeth Nietzsche's husband?
2. What was Nueva Germania?
3. What did Elisabeth found in 1894?
4. What did later scholars find Elisabeth had done to his letters?
5. Which of Nietzsche's views clashed most with Nazi ideology?
6. To whom did Nietzsche apply the image of the "blond beast"?
7. What did Walter Kaufmann's 1950 book do for Nietzsche's reputation?
8. What did Philippa Foot argue about Nietzsche?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia