Skip to main content

Provoking Austria

Through the spring of 1859 Cavour did everything he could to make Austria strike first. Piedmont called up reservists, welcomed deserters and volunteers from Lombardy, and gave Garibaldi command of a volunteer corps called the Hunters of the Alps. Britain tried to mediate, and for a moment it looked as if the plot would fail. Then Austria lost patience. On 23 April 1859 Vienna sent an ultimatum demanding that Piedmont disarm within three days. Cavour refused, Austrian troops crossed the border, and France came in as Piedmont's ally against an apparent aggressor. Cavour had got exactly the war he wanted.

Magenta and Solferino

The French army moved by rail and in large numbers, and the Austrian command was slow. The allies won at Magenta on 4 June, and Napoleon III and Victor Emmanuel rode into Milan a few days later. On 24 June came the huge battle of Solferino, with the Piedmontese fighting at nearby San Martino. Together the two June battles drove Austria out of Lombardy. Solferino involved roughly a quarter of a million soldiers and left tens of thousands dead, wounded or missing in a single day. The French emperor rode over the field and was badly shaken.

The shock of Villafranca

Then, without consulting Cavour, Napoleon III met the Austrian emperor Franz Joseph and agreed an armistice at Villafranca on 11 July 1859. His reasons were several. The war was costly and bloody. French Catholics feared for the pope. Napoleon did not want a strong kingdom on France's border. Most pressing, Prussia was mobilizing troops on the Rhine, and France could not risk a second front. Under the terms, Lombardy would pass to Piedmont, while Austria kept Venetia. The rulers of the central duchies were supposed to return, and Italy was to become a confederation under the pope.

Cavour was furious. After a stormy scene with his king he resigned in protest. To many patriots it seemed that Italy had been sold out once more by a foreign protector.

Central Italy decides for itself

Yet events on the ground had moved past the diplomats. When war began, the rulers of Tuscany, Modena and Parma had fled, and the papal province of Romagna had thrown off papal rule. Provisional governments took over. In Tuscany the leading figure was Baron Bettino Ricasoli, a stern landowner who pressed steadily for union with Piedmont. In Modena, Parma and Romagna, grouped as Emilia, Luigi Carlo Farini did the same. Elected assemblies voted for union with Piedmont and refused to take back their old rulers.

Austria could not easily restore the dukes without a new war, and Napoleon III would not do it for them. Britain, now led by ministers sympathetic to Italy, argued that Italians should be left to settle their own affairs. In January 1860 Cavour returned to power and struck a new bargain. France would accept the annexation of central Italy. In return, Piedmont would hand over Savoy and Nice, the price that had been agreed at Plombières for a larger result. The Treaty of Turin was signed on 24 March 1860.

Plebiscites and consent

To give these changes legitimacy, Cavour and his allies used plebiscites, popular votes on a single question. In the plebiscites of March 1860 in Tuscany and Emilia, all men aged twenty-one and over could vote, far more than could vote in Piedmont's own elections. Plebiscites in Nice and Savoy in April then approved union with France. Garibaldi, who was born in Nice, raged that he had been made a foreigner in his own birthplace.

Worked example: what did the plebiscites prove?

In Tuscany several hundred thousand men voted for union with Piedmont and only about fifteen thousand voted for a separate kingdom. Results in Emilia were even more lopsided. Supporters of unification then and since have pointed to these votes as proof that Italians freely chose Italy.

A careful reader should ask harder questions. Who organized the vote? The provisional governments that wanted union. Was the ballot secret? Often voters received printed ballots in public, and in some villages landlords or officials led peasants to the polls in procession. What were the choices? Union or a vague separate kingdom; restoring the old ruler was not on offer. Were women included? No. And the near-unanimous votes in Nice and Savoy for France, held under similar conditions, suggest how far the outcome reflected who ran the process.

None of this means the votes were meaningless. Large numbers of townspeople clearly did want union, and the plebiscites involved more men than any vote in Italian history before them. The idea that a people's consent, not a dynasty's claim, made a government legitimate was itself a step toward democracy. But consent organized from above is different from consent freely given, and historians weigh these results with care rather than taking them at face value.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Austria's ultimatum of April 1859 demand?
2. Which two battles of June 1859 drove Austria from Lombardy?
3. What were the main terms agreed at Villafranca?
4. Which threat helped push Napoleon III to make peace?
5. How did Cavour respond to the armistice of Villafranca?
6. Who led Tuscany toward union with Piedmont in 1859?
7. What did France receive in return for accepting the annexations?
8. Who could vote in the plebiscites of March 1860?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia