Skip to main content

The biblical golden age

According to the books of Samuel and Kings, the tribes asked for a king to face the Philistines. Saul, the first, failed and died in battle. David, a shepherd who became a warrior, united the tribes, took Jerusalem from the Jebusites and made it his capital. His son Solomon built a temple and a palace, married a pharaoh's daughter, and ruled a wealthy realm stretching from Egypt's border to the Euphrates. On Solomon's death, around 930 BCE in the usual chronology, the kingdom split in two: Israel in the north and Judah in the south.

The story is also unusually frank. David is a gifted ruler who commits adultery with Bathsheba and arranges her husband's death, and the prophet Nathan confronts him with a parable. The idea that a king stands under a moral law he did not make, and can be rebuked by a commoner, would echo through later political thought.

The Tel Dan Stele

Was David real? For a time some minimalists doubted it. Then in 1993 and 1994, at Tel Dan in northern Israel, excavators under Avraham Biran found pieces of a basalt victory inscription in Aramaic. Its author, most likely Hazael, king of Aram-Damascus, boasts of killing the king of Israel and a king of "the house of David." The stele dates to the ninth century BCE, more than a century after David's supposed reign. It shows that a dynasty in Judah was known by David's name, which makes it very likely that David was a real founder. A few scholars questioned the reading at first, but most now accept it.

The stele also creates a puzzle. Hazael claims the two kills, while the Bible, in Second Kings, credits the deaths of those same kings to the Israelite rebel Jehu. Perhaps Jehu acted as Hazael's ally, perhaps one of them claimed credit for the other's deed. Either way, sources that agree on a fact can disagree about who did it.

High chronology and low chronology

Existence is one question; size is another. In the 1950s and 1960s the Israeli archaeologist Yigael Yadin linked grand six-chambered gates at Hazor, Megiddo and Gezer with a verse in First Kings saying Solomon built those three cities. In 1996 Israel Finkelstein proposed a low chronology, shifting the dates of these buildings down by about a century, into the ninth century BCE. That would make them the work of the northern Omride kings, not Solomon. On this view tenth century Jerusalem was a small highland town and David and Solomon were local chiefs whose glory was enlarged by later writers.

Defenders of a stronger tenth century kingdom, such as Amihai Mazar, answer that radiocarbon results allow a "modified conventional" chronology and that Jerusalem is hard to excavate because later building has destroyed or covered so much. In 2005 Eilat Mazar announced a large stone building in the City of David that she identified as David's palace. Many archaeologists dispute whether this building dates to David's time, and the arguments continue.

What can be said fairly

A careful summary runs like this. A king named David very probably founded a dynasty in Judah. A kingdom of some kind existed around Jerusalem in the tenth century BCE. Whether it was a substantial state ruling the northern tribes or a modest chiefdom is genuinely disputed. The Bible's picture of an empire to the Euphrates has no support in records of neighboring powers, which never mention Solomon. But those neighbors were weak in this period, so their silence proves less than it would in a better documented age. The stakes reach well beyond archaeology. Later Jewish and Christian tradition made David the model king and the ancestor of a hoped-for messiah, so arguments over his kingdom can stir feelings that a dispute over pottery normally would not.

Worked example: Khirbet Qeiyafa

From 2007 to 2013 Yosef Garfinkel and Saar Ganor excavated a small fortified site called Khirbet Qeiyafa, overlooking the Elah Valley, where the Bible sets the duel of David and Goliath. They found a strong casemate wall, two gates, and an ink inscription on a pottery shard. Radiocarbon dates on olive pits put the main layer around 1000 BCE, give or take a few decades. The town was occupied only briefly.

Garfinkel argued that the site was a Judahite fortress built by a central authority, evidence that a state existed in David's time. He pointed to the absence of pig bones and to town planning similar to later Judahite towns. Critics offered other readings. Some suggested it belonged to a Canaanite or Philistine group, others to a northern polity linked with Saul, and still others that a fortified town does not need a kingdom behind it.

Notice the structure of the debate. Everyone accepts the wall, the dates and the shard. They disagree about who built the wall and what it implies. The physical evidence narrows the range of possible stories, ruling out an empty land, but it does not choose among the remaining stories by itself. That last step depends on argument, comparison and judgment.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Who most likely wrote the Tel Dan Stele?
2. What does the Tel Dan Stele show about Judah's rulers?
3. What did Israel Finkelstein's low chronology propose?
4. If the low chronology is right, who built the great gates once credited to Solomon?
5. What do many archaeologists dispute about Eilat Mazar's large stone building?
6. What do records of neighboring powers say about Solomon's empire?
7. According to the biblical account, who first united the tribes and took Jerusalem?
8. When does the usual chronology place the split into Israel and Judah?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia