Skip to main content

A narrow land between empires

The kingdoms of Israel and Judah grew up in the southern Levant, the strip of land between the Mediterranean Sea and the Arabian desert. From the coast to the Jordan River is rarely more than about eighty kilometers. Within that small space lie a fertile coastal plain, a spine of limestone hills, the deep rift of the Jordan Valley and the Dead Sea, and the dry Negev in the south. The region was a land bridge between Egypt and Mesopotamia, so traders, pilgrims and armies of great empires crossed it again and again. Its history is in large part the story of small peoples trying to survive in the path of giants.

Unlike Egypt or Babylonia, the hill country had no great river to flood the fields each year. Farming in the highlands depended on winter rain, collected in cisterns and terraces cut into the slopes. A dry year meant hunger. The book of Deuteronomy draws the contrast itself, describing Egypt as a land watered by human labor and the promised land as one that drinks the rain of heaven. Neighbors crowded close: Philistine cities on the southern coast, Phoenician ports to the north, the Aramaean kingdom of Damascus, and Ammon, Moab and Edom east and south of the Jordan.

The Bible as a historical source

The main written source for this history is the Hebrew Bible, which Jews call the Tanakh, after its three parts: Torah (teaching or law), Nevi'im (prophets) and Ketuvim (writings). It is a library rather than a single book, holding law, poetry, proverbs, royal history, prophecy and short stories, written and edited over many centuries. Most scholars think much of its narrative reached something close to its present form between the seventh and fifth centuries BCE, often long after the events it describes.

In 1878 the German scholar Julius Wellhausen gave classic form to the documentary hypothesis, the theory that the first five books were woven together from several earlier written sources, usually labeled J, E, D and P. Later scholars have revised the model heavily, and many now speak of blocks of tradition rather than four neat documents. Most still agree that the Torah is a composite, which helps explain why it sometimes tells the same story twice in different ways.

Digging and reading stones

Archaeology supplies a second kind of evidence. Ancient towns in the region were rebuilt on their own ruins until they formed artificial mounds called tells, with the oldest layers at the bottom. Excavators date these layers by pottery styles, by coins in later periods, and increasingly by radiocarbon tests on seeds and bones. A third source is inscriptions written by Israel's neighbors and rivals: Egyptian, Assyrian, Babylonian, Moabite and Aramaean kings who mentioned Israel and Judah for their own reasons. These texts are independent of the Bible, though they have their own boasts and blind spots. The earliest known mention of Israel outside the Bible is on the Merneptah Stele, an Egyptian victory monument of about 1208 BCE.

Maximalists, minimalists and the middle

In the 1990s the field split into loud camps. Scholars nicknamed minimalists, among them Niels Peter Lemche and Thomas L. Thompson in Copenhagen and Philip Davies in Sheffield, argued that the biblical story of early Israel was largely composed in the Persian or Hellenistic periods, so it tells us more about those later writers than about the Iron Age. Their critics, sometimes called maximalists, held that the biblical account should be trusted unless evidence contradicts it. The archaeologist William Dever attacked the minimalists sharply while also rejecting much of the older, more confident picture.

Most historians now work in the space between. They treat the Bible as a source to be tested, neither accepted whole nor dismissed whole, comparing it with excavation and inscriptions case by case. Two cautions apply. Absence of evidence is not always evidence of absence, since much has been lost or never dug. Yet when large and searched-for remains fail to appear, silence starts to count. Whatever the verdict on particular events, the moral ideas of these texts, such as care for the stranger and the claim that every person bears the image of God, have their own long history of influence.

Worked example: What the Merneptah Stele does and does not prove

In 1896 the British archaeologist Flinders Petrie found a tall granite slab in the ruins of a temple at Thebes. Its hieroglyphic text celebrates the victories of the pharaoh Merneptah, son of Ramesses II. Near the end it lists defeated places in Canaan: Ashkelon, Gezer, Yanoam. Then comes a line usually translated "Israel is laid waste, his seed is not."

Start with what the text says. Egyptian writing added silent signs, called determinatives, to show what kind of thing a word named. Ashkelon, Gezer and Yanoam carry the sign for a foreign land or city. Israel carries the sign for a people. So around 1208 BCE there was a group called Israel in Canaan, large enough for a pharaoh to boast of crushing it, but probably not yet a territorial state.

Now ask what it does not say. It says nothing about Egypt as a place Israel had left, nothing about a king, and nothing exact about where Israel lived. The boast that Israel's seed was destroyed was plainly false, since Israel outlived Merneptah's dynasty. Victory hymns exaggerate. The careful conclusion is modest but solid: a people named Israel was already in the land by the late thirteenth century BCE. Any theory of Israel's origins has to fit that fact.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What made the southern Levant a route for armies and traders?
2. What did farming in the highland hill country mainly depend on?
3. Why is the Hebrew Bible described as a library rather than one book?
4. What does the documentary hypothesis propose?
5. What is distinctive about the inscriptions of Israel's neighbors as evidence?
6. Where is the earliest known mention of Israel outside the Bible?
7. What did the scholars nicknamed minimalists argue?
8. How do most historians now treat the Bible as a source?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia