Skip to main content

The arrival of Europeans did not begin with conquest. For the Haudenosaunee it began with trade, disease and a new kind of war. Over the 1600s the league became one of the most feared powers in northeastern North America, and also suffered losses that would have shattered a less resilient society.

The Dutch and the Mohawk

Dutch traders built a post on the upper Hudson River in 1614, and in 1624 the Dutch West India Company founded Fort Orange, near present-day Albany. The Mohawk, Keepers of the Eastern Door, controlled access to it. In exchange for beaver pelts they obtained metal kettles, axes, knives, cloth, glass beads and, increasingly, guns and ammunition, which the Dutch traded more freely than the French did to their own allies. By the 1640s Mohawk warriors were among the best-armed fighters on the continent.

Trade also brought disease. Europeans carried smallpox, measles and influenza, to which Indigenous peoples had no prior exposure. A Dutch surgeon named Harmen van den Bogaert, who traveled through Mohawk and Oneida country in the winter of 1634 to 1635, described towns suffering from smallpox. Epidemics in the 1630s and 1640s may have killed half or more of the Haudenosaunee population, though exact numbers are uncertain.

The logic of the mourning war

Haudenosaunee warfare had long served purposes different from European war. When a person died, especially through violence, grieving relatives, often led by women, could call for a raid to bring back captives. Some captives were killed, but many were adopted to replace the dead, taking their names and places in families. Historians call this the mourning war. It was a way of keeping a community whole in the face of loss.

After the epidemics, the demand for captives rose sharply. Mourning wars merged with competition over furs and hunting grounds, and the Haudenosaunee launched a series of campaigns against their neighbors in the middle of the century. The Wendat confederacy was dispersed, and in the following years the Neutral and the Erie nations were also broken up, with thousands of their people absorbed into Haudenosaunee towns. At times adopted outsiders may have made up a majority in some Seneca and Mohawk villages.

What to call these wars

These conflicts are often called the Beaver Wars, a name that emphasizes the fur trade. Some historians think the name is misleading. It can overstate the fur trade as a cause, suggesting the Haudenosaunee were simply fighting for European goods, when the mourning war tradition, revenge, adoption and older rivalries mattered just as much. Others reply that the fur trade really did reshape the scale and aims of the fighting. Both causes were probably at work, and their weight varied from one campaign to the next.

Missions, divisions and French attack

French Jesuit missionaries worked among the Haudenosaunee from the 1650s, and some converts moved north to mission settlements near Montreal. The most famous was Kateri Tekakwitha, a Mohawk and Algonquin woman born in 1656 at Ossernenon, who was baptized in 1676, moved to the mission at Kahnawake and died there in 1680. The Catholic Church canonized her in 2012. Mission communities such as Kahnawake grew into lasting Mohawk towns, but they also divided the nation between those who stayed and those who left.

France struck back at the league repeatedly. In 1687 the governor of New France, the Marquis de Denonville, invaded Seneca country and burned towns and huge stores of corn, including the large town of Ganondagan, now a New York State historic site. Years of raids and counter-raids followed until the peace treaties of 1701, after which the league largely kept a careful balance between France and England.

Worked example: the Two Row Wampum

One of the best-known Haudenosaunee belts is the Two Row Wampum, or Kaswentha. It is a belt of white beads with two parallel rows of purple beads running its length. In the Haudenosaunee reading, one row is a Haudenosaunee canoe and the other a European ship. They travel side by side down the same river, in peace and friendship, but neither tries to steer the other's vessel. The white beads between them stand for peace, friendship and respect.

Tradition links the belt to an agreement with the Dutch, often dated to 1613. Here the historian must separate two questions. A written Dutch treaty from 1613, published in the twentieth century, was examined by scholars in the 1980s, and most concluded that the 1613 document is a forgery. Yet the principle the belt records is well attested in later Haudenosaunee diplomacy, where speakers repeatedly invoked two vessels traveling side by side. The case is a useful lesson: a doubtful document does not erase a real tradition, and a strong tradition does not prove a particular document. Today the Two Row is often cited in debates about sovereignty, as a model of two peoples sharing land while keeping their own laws.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Where did the Dutch found Fort Orange?
2. What did the Dutch trade more freely than the French?
3. How deadly were the epidemics of the 1630s and 1640s?
4. What happened to many captives in a mourning war?
5. Which nations were broken up after the Wendat?
6. Why do some historians dislike the name Beaver Wars?
7. Where was Kateri Tekakwitha born?
8. Which Seneca town did Denonville burn in 1687?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia