Skip to main content

The Great Law created a council that met at Onondaga and spoke for the league as a whole. It did not replace the councils of each nation, which still handled their own affairs. The Grand Council dealt with matters that touched everyone: peace and war with outsiders, disputes between member nations, and the reception of foreign embassies. Its design reflected the founding story at every turn.

Fifty titles

The council was made up of chiefs who held specific, named titles, often called royaner or hoyaneh, words meaning roughly "good" or "of the good mind." There were fifty titles in all, divided unevenly among the nations: the Onondaga held fourteen, the Cayuga ten, the Mohawk nine, the Oneida nine and the Seneca eight. The numbers did not translate into votes, because the council did not decide by counting heads. Each nation's chiefs reached a single position first and spoke with one voice.

A title was not personal property. Each title belonged to a particular clan within a nation, and when its holder died, the title passed to another man of the same clan, who took the name of the office. In this sense the original fifty chiefs never died: the names have been raised again and again. Alongside these hereditary chiefs, the league later recognized Pine Tree Chiefs, men honored for their personal merit who could speak in council but held no hereditary title.

Sides of the fire

The council was arranged like a family. The Mohawk and Seneca, with the Onondaga, were called the Elder Brothers, and the Oneida and Cayuga were the Younger Brothers. The Onondaga served as the Firekeepers, and Tadodaho chaired the meeting.

In the usual description, a matter was first discussed by the Mohawk, who reached agreement among themselves and passed it to the Seneca. When the Elder Brothers agreed, the question crossed the fire to the Oneida and Cayuga, who considered it in turn. If the two sides agreed, the decision went to the Onondaga Firekeepers to confirm. If the sides disagreed, the Firekeepers could try to resolve the difference or send the matter back for more discussion. The aim was consensus, described in the phrase "one mind," and a decision that did not have it would usually be set aside rather than forced.

The duties of a chief

The Great Law demanded much of chiefs. Parker's 1916 version tells them to keep in view "not only the present but also the coming generations," and to put self-interest aside. Popular writing today often speaks of the seventh generation principle, the idea that leaders should weigh how their choices will affect people seven generations in the future. The exact phrase is a modern summary, but it draws on this old teaching. Chiefs were also expected to be patient under criticism, a quality described as having skin "seven spans" thick.

A sixth nation

The Tuscarora, an Iroquoian people from what is now North Carolina, were driven north after a war with British colonists and their allies in 1711 to 1713. They moved among the Oneida, and in the 1720s the league accepted them as a sixth nation. The Tuscarora did not receive new hereditary titles on the Grand Council; they were represented through the Oneida, who had sponsored them. This shows how the league could grow: other peoples could follow the white roots and take shelter, but the original structure stayed in place.

Limits and strengths

Consensus has obvious costs. A single nation could delay or block a decision, and during crises the league often failed to act as one. In wartime, individual nations, villages and even war leaders made their own choices, and outsiders sometimes mistook the voice of one nation for the voice of all. Yet the same design made the peace remarkably durable. Because no nation could be outvoted on a matter of life and death, none had a reason to leave, and the league held together for centuries.

Worked example: a message from the governor

Picture a summer in the 1740s. A runner arrives at Onondaga with a message from a colonial governor asking the league to join a war against the French. The Firekeepers send runners to call the chiefs. When the council opens, it begins with the Thanksgiving Address, so that minds are brought together before anything else.

The Mohawk chiefs discuss the request first. They trade with the English at Albany and lean toward agreeing. They pass their view to the Seneca, whose towns lie close to French forts on the Great Lakes and who fear French reprisals. After long talks, the Elder Brothers agree only to a cautious answer: the league will not attack the French but will keep the path to Albany open. The proposal crosses the fire. The Oneida and Cayuga accept it. The Onondaga confirm it, and a speaker is chosen to deliver the reply with a belt of wampum. The governor wanted a yes or a no. What he receives is a middle path shaped so that every nation can accept it, which is exactly what the system was designed to produce.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. How many chief titles did the Great Law create?
2. Which nation held the most council titles?
3. Who owned each hereditary chief's title?
4. Who were the Pine Tree Chiefs?
5. What did the Grand Council aim for in decisions?
6. What does the seventh generation principle ask of leaders?
7. Where did the Tuscarora come from?
8. How were the Tuscarora seated on the Grand Council?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia