Skip to main content

The last family of criticisms is political. It asks not whether effective altruists reason well about individual choices, but whether the whole frame of individual choice leaves something out. In 2022 those questions stopped being abstract.

Srinivasan's review

In 2015 the philosopher Amia Srinivasan reviewed MacAskill's Doing Good Better in the London Review of Books. In paraphrase, Srinivasan argued that effective altruism takes the existing economic and political order largely for granted. Its method suits a consumer choosing among products on a shelf. It has much to say about which charity to fund and little to say about why some people need charity and others can afford to give it. She also suggested that the movement's language of neutral calculation hides contestable values, and that its arithmetic could be stretched to make almost any project look like the best use of money.

The systemic change objection

Srinivasan's review joined a wider argument. The systemic change objection holds that charity treats symptoms while leaving unjust institutions in place. On this view, poverty is not a natural disaster like a drowning; it is sustained by laws, trade rules, debts, wars and the conduct of powerful states. The philosopher Iason Gabriel set out this and related criticisms carefully in a 2017 paper.

The economist Angus Deaton added a warning about aid itself. Deaton argued that large flows of aid can make governments answer to donors rather than to their own citizens, weakening the bond of accountability on which good government depends.

Effective altruists reply that their framework can include systemic change whenever the evidence supports it. Open Philanthropy funded campaigns for criminal justice reform, for zoning changes to allow more housing, and for corporate pledges to stop keeping hens in cages. Critics answer that such projects remain chosen by a few wealthy donors and that the movement has rarely backed the kind of mass political organizing through which the poor have historically won their rights.

The FTX collapse

In 2019 Sam Bankman-Fried, the former MIT student MacAskill had spoken with in 2012, founded the cryptocurrency exchange FTX. Within three years he was a billionaire and the movement's most famous donor, promising to give nearly all his fortune away. His FTX Future Fund, with MacAskill among its advisers, made grants to longtermist projects.

In November 2022 FTX collapsed. It emerged that customer deposits had been secretly moved to Alameda Research, Bankman-Fried's trading firm, and billions of dollars were missing. The exchange filed for bankruptcy within days, and the Future Fund's team resigned. Bankman-Fried was convicted of fraud and conspiracy in 2023 and in 2024 sentenced to twenty-five years in prison. MacAskill wrote that he had been deceived and that he was ashamed of having trusted him.

Lessons drawn

Critics drew several lessons. Earning to give had led the movement to celebrate a man in a lightly regulated, speculative industry. Its focus on vast expected payoffs could, they argued, encourage reckless risk-taking. And many critics saw the collapse as a warning about concentrating a movement's funding in a few donors, whose conduct few insiders were in a position to question.

Defenders answered that the fraud betrayed the movement rather than expressing it. Leading effective altruists responded that fraud for the sake of good causes violates their own principles, and they pointed to years of writing that warned against causing harm for the greater good. Philosophers in the consequentialist tradition have long made a related point. Sophisticated consequentialists argue that following firm rules, such as honesty, usually produces better outcomes than case-by-case calculation, because people who trust their own sums when breaking rules are usually wrong. In the years that followed, several of the movement's organizations reformed their governance and widened their sources of money.

Weighing the movement

Seen from a distance, effective altruism has done things its critics might envy: large numbers of children protected from malaria, millions of hens moved out of cages, early attention to pandemics. It has also shown how quickly a movement built on careful reasoning can be captured by money and confidence.

Each side guards something about human dignity. Singer's impartiality insists that a stranger's child is worth as much as your own neighbor's. Williams insists that persons are not channels for outcomes. Srinivasan and the systemic critics insist that the poor are agents and citizens, not only recipients. A thoughtful response keeps all three in view.

Worked example: the generous founder

A university group that raises money for global health is offered 2 million dollars by a young founder whose company operates in a fast-growing, lightly regulated industry. The gift would multiply the group's budget twentyfold.

Apply what the FTX story teaches. How does the company make its money, and could that business be harming the people the group wants to help? Would the group become dependent on one donor, unable to criticize him? Who in the group is able to ask hard questions, and would they be heard? The systemic critic adds another: could the same energy do more by pressing for laws that make such industries safer? None of these questions forbids taking the gift. Together they mark the difference between doing good carefully and merely doing good confidently.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Srinivasan argue about effective altruism?
2. What does the systemic change objection hold?
3. What did Deaton argue about large flows of aid?
4. What emerged when FTX collapsed in 2022?
5. What sentence did Bankman-Fried receive?
6. What lesson did many critics draw from the FTX collapse?
7. How did leading effective altruists respond to the fraud?
8. What do sophisticated consequentialists argue?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia