In January 1959 almost nobody, perhaps including Castro himself, knew what kind of government would follow. The first cabinet was led by moderates: the judge Manuel Urrutia became president and the lawyer José Miró Cardona prime minister. Castro took command of the armed forces, and in February Fidel Castro became prime minister. Within three years Cuba was a one party socialist state allied with the Soviet Union.
Justice or vengeance
Revolutionary tribunals tried soldiers and police accused of murder and torture under Batista. Several hundred were executed in 1959, though counts differ. A trial of one notorious officer, held before a jeering crowd in a Havana sports arena in January, drew criticism abroad. Defenders of the tribunals argued that public anger at Batista's torturers would otherwise have produced lynchings, as had happened after Machado's fall in 1933. Critics replied that the trials lacked basic guarantees, and they noted that the same methods were soon turned against revolutionaries who dissented. Huber Matos, a rebel commander who protested communist influence and resigned in October 1959, was arrested and sentenced to twenty years in prison.
Castro had promised elections. They were postponed indefinitely. The government argued that mass rallies, where Castro spoke for hours and crowds roared approval, were a more direct democracy than the corrupt elections of the past.
Land and the early reforms
The government cut rents and electricity rates, opened private beaches to the public and campaigned against racial discrimination in clubs and hiring. The Agrarian Reform Law of May 1959 capped most holdings at about 400 hectares, gave titles to tenants and squatters, and expropriated large estates, including American owned sugar lands. Compensation was promised in bonds based on the owners' own tax valuations, which many had kept low; it was never paid to American owners. Much of the land became state farms and cooperatives rather than family plots.
The spiral of 1960
In February 1960 the Soviet deputy premier Anastas Mikoyan visited Havana and agreed to buy Cuban sugar and supply oil and credit. In June, when the first Soviet crude arrived, the American and British oil companies on the island, encouraged by Washington, refused to refine Soviet crude, and the government seized their refineries. In July President Eisenhower cut the American quota for Cuban sugar. Between August and October Cuba nationalized American companies, then large Cuban businesses, the banks and rental housing. In October the United States banned most exports to Cuba, and in January 1961 the two countries broke diplomatic relations.
The revolution organized society as it went. In September 1960 Castro launched the Committees for the Defense of the Revolution, block groups that watched neighbors for signs of opposition. Many middle class and professional Cubans left, roughly two hundred thousand by the end of 1962. Fearing rumors that the state would take custody of their children, parents arranged Operation Pedro Pan, in which about 14,000 children were sent alone to the US between 1960 and 1962.
Socialism declared
The CIA had begun planning an invasion by Cuban exiles in March 1960. On 16 April 1961, at a funeral for victims of air raids that preceded the landing, Castro first declared the revolution socialist, on the eve of an invasion. The exile force that landed at the Bay of Pigs the next day was defeated in under three days, and most of its men were captured and later exchanged for food and medicine. The same year a literacy campaign sent tens of thousands of young volunteers into the countryside. In December Castro declared himself a Marxist-Leninist, and in February 1962 the United States imposed a nearly total embargo.
In October 1962 the discovery of Soviet nuclear missiles in Cuba brought the world close to war. Castro was not consulted when Khrushchev agreed to withdraw them. Furious, he refused to allow UN inspections on Cuban soil.
Worked example: who pushed whom?
Did Castro plan a communist state from the start, or did American hostility push a nationalist into Soviet arms? Each side has evidence. Raúl Castro and Guevara were Marxists well before 1959, and Castro later said he had long held such views. On the other side, Castro told American audiences in April 1959 that he was not a communist, the old Communist party had been a late and junior partner, and the American decision to cut the sugar quota left Cuba few buyers except Moscow.
A third reading treats the break as an interaction. Castro wanted a radical revolution that would end Cuba's dependence on the United States, and that goal collided with American property and power. Each side's moves narrowed the other's options: the refinery seizures followed the oil dispute, the quota cut followed the seizures, and the nationalizations followed the quota cut. Castro also used the conflict to sideline moderates, since foreign threat made dissent look like treason. The lesson is that a sequence of events is not yet an explanation. To explain, ask what each actor wanted, what choices each believed it had, and which moves closed doors that could not be reopened.
