Skip to main content

In 1870 Paris was the most admired city in Europe and one of the most divided. Visitors came for the new boulevards, the department stores and the opera. Many of the people who built and served that city lived in crowded districts on its edges and had voted, again and again, against the man who ruled it. To understand why Paris rose in 1871, start with the twenty years before.

The Second Empire

Louis-Napoléon Bonaparte, nephew of the first Napoleon, had been elected president of France in 1848, seized full power in a coup at the end of 1851 and became Emperor Napoleon III a year later. His regime, the Second Empire, combined universal male suffrage with tight control. Voters could approve or reject, but the press was licensed, public meetings were restricted, and official candidates enjoyed the help of prefects and mayors appointed from above.

The regime also presided over rapid growth. Railways spread across the country, new investment banks financed industry and public works, and great international exhibitions in Paris, in 1855 and 1867, showed off French products to millions of visitors. Prosperity was real, but it was unevenly shared, and the capital felt the inequality most sharply.

Paris itself had almost no self-government. The city was run by the prefect of the Seine, an official appointed by the emperor, not by an elected mayor. Governments since the great revolution had feared that a capital with its own elected leader could challenge the nation, and the Empire shared that fear. The demand for municipal liberty, the right of Parisians to govern their own city, would become one of the deepest roots of the Commune.

Haussmann's Paris

From 1853 to 1870 the prefect Georges-Eugène Haussmann rebuilt the capital. He cut long, straight boulevards through medieval streets, laid sewers and water mains, created parks and lined the new avenues with uniform stone apartment blocks. Admirers saw light, air and health. Critics noticed that wide, straight roads were also harder to barricade and easier for troops to cross.

The rebuilding had a social cost. Demolitions destroyed tens of thousands of cheap lodgings in the center, rents rose, and many working families were pushed toward the eastern and northern edges of the city, into districts such as Belleville and Montmartre. In 1860 Paris annexed its surrounding villages and grew from twelve districts, called arrondissements, to twenty. The result was a city increasingly sorted by class: prosperous west, laboring east.

Workers and trades

Paris was not a city of giant factories. Most Parisian workers labored in small workshops and skilled trades: furniture, jewelry, printing, building, clothing, metalwork and the luxury goods known as articles de Paris. Many were artisans who prized independence and dreamed of running their own workshops through cooperatives rather than working for a master.

The Empire tried to win them over. In 1864 a new law allowed strikes, under conditions. That same year workers from several countries met in London and founded the International Workingmen's Association, usually called the First International, which soon had French branches. Bookbinders, bronze workers and other trades organized, and the young bookbinder Eugène Varlin became one of the best known labor organizers in Paris.

The liberal Empire

In the late 1860s Napoleon III loosened his grip. Laws of 1868 eased controls on the press and allowed public meetings. The result surprised him. Hundreds of meetings in halls and dance rooms filled with talk of socialism, cooperation, religion and the republic. New radical newspapers appeared, and in the elections of 1869 Paris voted overwhelmingly for opposition candidates.

In May 1870 the emperor asked the nation to approve his liberal reforms in a plebiscite. Across France more than seven million voted yes, but Paris returned a large majority against the regime. The emperor seemed secure in the country as a whole. His capital was another matter, and that gap between Paris and the provinces would shape everything that followed.

Worked example: a cabinetmaker in Belleville

Imagine a cabinetmaker in 1869. Ten years earlier he lived near the Hôtel de Ville, a short walk from the workshops of the Faubourg Saint-Antoine where he finds work. His building was demolished for a new boulevard. He now rents two rooms in Belleville, annexed to Paris in 1860, and walks an hour each way.

Follow how the forces described above reach him. Rebuilding has raised his rent and moved him to the edge of a city that is sorting itself by class. His trade is skilled and his workshop is small, so he hears talk of cooperatives as a way to keep his independence. The press laws of 1868 let him attend public meetings in a local hall, where speakers attack the Empire and debate whether workers should own their tools together. He cannot vote for a mayor, because Paris has none.

None of this makes him a revolutionary. It does make him someone with grievances about rent, work and self-government, a habit of discussing politics in public, and a strong sense that the capital is governed for others. When war, siege and hunger arrived, men and women like him had already learned to see the state as something done to them rather than by them.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Who ran the city of Paris under the Second Empire?
2. Where were many working families pushed by Haussmann's rebuilding?
3. How many arrondissements did Paris have after the annexation of 1860?
4. Where did most Parisian workers labor in the 1860s?
5. What organization did workers from several countries found in London in 1864?
6. What did a French law of 1864 allow, under conditions?
7. How did Paris vote in the plebiscite of May 1870?
8. What did critics notice about Haussmann's wide, straight boulevards?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia