Charlemagne's rule was not only about conquest and estates. He and his advisers believed that God would judge the Franks by how correctly they worshipped, and that a priest who garbled the words of the mass or a monk who copied the Bible badly put souls at risk. Their program, which modern historians call the Carolingian Renaissance, was at heart a campaign of correction: of texts, of Latin, of worship and of behavior.
Correcting the church
A circular letter sent in the king's name, probably in the 780s, to Abbot Baugulf of Fulda set out the problem. The Letter on Cultivating Learning complained of poor Latin in letters from monasteries: the monks' prayers were pious, but their grammar was so bad that the king feared they could not understand Scripture properly either. The remedy was study.
In 789 a long capitulary called the Admonitio generalis, the General Admonition, set out rules for clergy and laity alike. The Admonitio generalis of 789 ordered schools at monasteries and cathedrals where boys would learn the psalms, musical notation, chant, the calculation of the church calendar and grammar, and it demanded that service books be corrected. The aim was a clergy able to read, sing and teach.
The court scholars
Charles drew learned men from across Europe. The Englishman Alcuin of York, whom he met in Italy in 781, became his chief adviser on learning until he retired as abbot of Saint-Martin at Tours, where he died in 804. Theodulf, a Visigoth from Spain, became bishop of Orléans. Paul the Deacon, a Lombard, wrote a History of the Lombards after a stay at the court. Einhard, a Frank educated at Fulda, oversaw building work and later wrote the king's biography. Einhard modeled his Life of Charlemagne on Suetonius's lives of the Caesars, borrowing its order of topics and even some of its phrases.
The court had a playful side. Members took nicknames from the Bible and the classics. Alcuin was Flaccus, after the Roman poet Horace. Charlemagne's court nickname was David, after the biblical king, a model of a ruler who was both warrior and singer of psalms.
Books and survival
The greatest legacy of the movement lay in its books. Monasteries such as Tours, Corbie, Fulda, Reichenau, Lorsch and St Gall built up workshops for copying, and scribes developed a clearer script that later printers revived. Several thousand manuscripts survive from the ninth century, far more than from the century before. Scribes copied Bibles, church fathers and law codes, but also Roman poets, historians and scientific writers. A large share of classical Latin literature reaches us only because Carolingian scribes copied it. The first six books of Tacitus's Annals survive in a single ninth-century manuscript. The oldest copies of Lucretius's poem On the Nature of Things also date from this time.
Buildings and images
At Aachen, Charles built a palace with a great hall and a domed, eight-sided chapel, consecrated around 805. The Palace Chapel at Aachen was inspired by San Vitale in Ravenna, a sixth-century church built when Ravenna was ruled from Constantinople, and its marble columns were brought from Ravenna and Rome. At Germigny-des-Prés, Theodulf built a small oratory whose apse mosaic shows the Ark of the Covenant rather than a figure of Christ.
That choice reflected a debate about images. In 787 a church council at Nicaea, called by Irene, restored the veneration of icons in the east. A poor Latin translation of its decisions reached the Franks, who believed the Greeks were demanding the worship of pictures. Theodulf wrote a long reply in the king's name. The Opus Caroli regis argued that images should be neither worshipped nor destroyed: they were useful for decoration and for reminding people of sacred events, but holiness lay in God, not in paint. A council at Frankfurt in 794 took the same line.
Who took part?
The renaissance reached a small elite: clergy above all, plus some nobles and royal women. Charlemagne's sister Gisela, abbess of Chelles, ran a house where nuns copied books, and his daughters studied at court. For most peasants, the changes arrived mainly as better-trained priests and more uniform services.
Worked example: how Tacitus survived
The Roman historian Tacitus wrote the Annals, a history of the emperors from Tiberius to Nero, early in the second century. No copy from antiquity survives. For the first six books, everything we know depends on a single manuscript written in the ninth century in a German monastery, most likely Fulda, and now kept in Florence. It lay unnoticed for centuries, reached Rome around 1508 and was printed in 1515.
A monk who never visited Rome, working for an abbey founded by a missionary, copied a pagan text that criticized emperors and mocked flatterers. The survival of ancient learning was not automatic. It depended on deliberate choices by people who believed that good Latin and good books served God, and on luck. When we read classical texts today, we are often reading what Carolingian copyists chose to keep.
