A monarchy restored
For seventeen years after the conquest Benin had no oba. British officials governed through a council of chiefs, part of a wider system in which colonial rulers worked through local authorities they controlled. When Ovonramwen died in exile, the British decided that a restored monarchy would make rule easier. In 1914 Ovonramwen's son was crowned as Oba Eweka II. He rebuilt part of the palace, revived royal rites and encouraged the guilds to make new works for the altars that had been stripped.
The kingdom became part of colonial Nigeria, and in 1960 of an independent Nigerian state. The oba has no formal power in Nigeria's constitution, but he remains a figure of great cultural and moral weight among the Edo. Oba Erediauwa reigned from 1979 to 2016, and his son, a former diplomat, was crowned in 2016 as Oba Ewuare II.
The palace has used its authority on modern problems. Many young women from Edo State have been trafficked to Europe, often bound by oaths sworn at shrines that frightened them into silence. In 2018 Oba Ewuare II revoked oaths used to bind trafficked women and placed a curse on those who carried out such rites, an act that some aid workers said helped victims speak out.
Scattered across the world
The objects taken in 1897 spread quickly. Many were sold to private collectors and dealers, and museums in Britain, Germany, the United States and elsewhere bought them in large numbers. Estimates of the total range from about three thousand to many more, and no complete list exists. The British Museum holds one of the largest collections, more than nine hundred objects.
Requests for return began decades ago, and Nigerian leaders pressed them after independence. Large British national museums face a legal barrier. The British Museum Act of 1963 limits the museum's power to give up objects in its collection, and successive governments have declined to change it. From 2010 a group of European museums and Nigerian representatives met as the Benin Dialogue Group, at first discussing loans and a new museum in Benin City rather than permanent returns.
The returns begin
The mood shifted around 2020. In October 2021 the University of Aberdeen returned a brass head of an oba, and Jesus College, Cambridge, returned a brass cockerel known as the Okukor, which students had campaigned to remove from display. In 2022 Germany agreed to transfer ownership of more than a thousand Benin objects in its public museums, and London's Horniman Museum transferred ownership of 72 objects. In October 2022 the Smithsonian's National Museum of African Art returned 29 Benin objects to Nigeria.
New questions followed. In March 2023 the outgoing Nigerian president, Muhammadu Buhari, issued a decree. A Nigerian decree of March 2023 recognized the oba as owner of returned objects, giving the palace authority over where they would be kept. Some European officials and Nigerian museum planners worried that the works might not go on public display. Supporters answered that the objects had been taken from the oba's palace and altars, so returning them to the palace was simply undoing the theft.
Another challenge came from the United States, from an organization of descendants of enslaved Americans. In a 2022 lawsuit, the Restitution Study Group argued descendants of enslaved people share a claim to the objects, because much of the brass came from manillas paid for captives in the Atlantic trade. Their case did not stop the Smithsonian's return, but it raised a hard question about whose suffering a work of art carries.
Worked example: who should hold a returned head?
Imagine a brass head from a royal altar, returned from a European museum. Four parties might claim it. How should the decision be weighed?
The oba's palace has the oldest claim. The head was made for the oba's ancestors and taken from his altar. For the palace it is a sacred object, not a museum piece, and the dynasty still exists.
The Nigerian state represents all its citizens and has led the diplomatic effort. It can argue that national heritage belongs to the nation and should be protected by public institutions.
The wider public, in Nigeria and abroad, has an interest in seeing and studying such works. A museum in Benin City could serve both pride and learning.
Descendants of the enslaved point to the metal itself and to the human cost of the trade that supplied it.
No rule settles every case, but some principles help. Taking by force does not create a fair title. Those from whom something was taken have the first claim to its return. Keeping a sacred object out of sight does not erase its value as heritage, and public access can be arranged by agreement. The returns of recent years show that what once seemed impossible can change, and that the hardest questions come after the return, when people must decide together what a recovered past should mean.
