Skip to main content

A people of the highlands

Armenians are one of the oldest continuous peoples of western Asia. For more than two thousand years they lived on the high plateau around Lake Van, Mount Ararat and the upper Euphrates, a land of long winters, deep valleys and fertile plains wedged between larger powers. Rome and Persia fought over it, then Byzantium and the Arab caliphate, then Turkic dynasties and Mongols, and finally the Ottomans and the Safavids of Iran, who divided most of it between them in the sixteenth century. Through all those conquests Armenians kept a language of their own, a church of their own and a strong sense that they belonged to this landscape.

Two achievements anchored that identity. By long tradition, the Kingdom of Armenia adopted Christianity as its state religion around 301, and Armenians count this as the first such adoption anywhere; some scholars prefer a slightly later date, around 314. About a century later, around 405, the monk Mesrop Mashtots created the Armenian alphabet, so that scripture and prayers could be read in Armenian rather than Greek or Syriac. The Armenian Apostolic Church, with its own hierarchy and calendar, became the institution that held a scattered people together when no Armenian king ruled. The last Armenian kingdom, in Cilicia on the Mediterranean coast, fell in 1375.

Living under Ottoman rule

Ottoman law sorted subjects by religion. Christians and Jews were protected communities who could worship and manage their own affairs, but they ranked below Muslims: they paid extra taxes, were barred from carrying arms, and their testimony counted for less in Islamic courts. For the Armenians, the state's main partner was the church. According to tradition, Sultan Mehmed II installed an Armenian patriarch in Constantinople in 1461, a few years after he conquered the city, and over time that patriarch became the official voice of Armenians before the government. Historians now think much of this arrangement took formal shape later than the tradition says, but by the nineteenth century the patriarchate was a real power, running schools, hospitals and registers of births and marriages.

Armenian life was not one thing. In Constantinople a small, wealthy circle of amiras, an elite of Armenian bankers and officials, served the court. They lent money to tax farmers, managed the imperial mint and, in the case of the Dadian family, ran the state gunpowder works. The Balian family of architects designed mosques, barracks and palaces for the sultans, including the Dolmabahçe Palace on the Bosphorus, completed in 1856. Armenian printers, photographers, doctors and actors were prominent in the capital's cultural life. Yet the great majority of Armenians were peasants in the eastern provinces, farming beside Kurdish, Turkish and other Muslim neighbors. In the mountains they often paid dues to Kurdish chiefs as well as taxes to the state.

Reform and its limits

In the nineteenth century Ottoman reformers promised equal citizenship to all subjects, whatever their faith. For Armenians the most striking result came from inside their own community. In 1863 the government approved an Armenian National Constitution that created an elected national assembly to run the community's schools, charities and church finances, with lay members outnumbering clergy. It was a rare experiment in representative government inside an absolute monarchy, and it trained a generation of Armenian lawyers, teachers and journalists in public argument.

Equality on paper did not always reach the villages. In the east, Armenian farmers complained to the patriarchate of land seizures, kidnappings and the double burden of state taxes and tribal dues, and petitions sent to the capital often went unanswered. The gap between the promise of equal citizenship and life in the provinces would shape everything that followed.

How many Armenians?

Numbers matter in this history, and they are disputed. On the eve of the First World War, the Armenian patriarchate counted a little over two million Armenians in the empire, while official Ottoman figures gave about 1.2 to 1.3 million. Ottoman censuses undercounted some groups and the church had its own reasons to count generously, so many historians place the true figure between the two, often around 1.5 to 2 million. Armenians were a minority almost everywhere, but in parts of six eastern provinces, among them Van, Bitlis and Erzurum, they formed large shares of the rural population. Those six provinces would become the center of every later argument.

Worked example: two Armenian lives in 1880

Picture two Armenians alive in 1880. One belongs to the Balian family in Constantinople, trained in Paris, sketching a pavilion for the sultan and attending debates of the national assembly. The other farms on the plain of Mush, west of Lake Van. He speaks Armenian at home and Kurdish at market, owes part of his harvest to a local chief, and has never seen the capital. Both belong to the same church, and both are, in law, Ottoman subjects.

Ask what each one needs from the state. The architect needs steady patronage and a court that values his skill. The farmer needs protection: a tax collector who takes only what the law allows, a judge who will hear him against a stronger Muslim neighbor, and soldiers who stop raids rather than join them. The Ottoman government supplied the first far more easily than the second. Holding both lives in view explains why Armenian politics later centered on security in the east, and why the fate of the provinces, not of the capital, became the heart of what Europeans soon called the Armenian Question.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. By long tradition, when did Armenia adopt Christianity as its state religion?
2. Who created the Armenian alphabet?
3. What did Mehmed II do in 1461, according to tradition?
4. Who were the amiras?
5. Which building did the Balian family of architects design?
6. Where did most Ottoman Armenians live in the nineteenth century?
7. What did the Armenian National Constitution of 1863 create?
8. How many Armenians did the patriarchate count on the eve of the First World War?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia