Skip to main content

A century of reformers

In the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries a wave of Muslim reform movements transformed West Africa. Many were led by Fulbe, or Fulani, scholars, members of a widely scattered people of herders and clerics. Earlier movements had created Muslim states in the highlands of Futa Jallon in the 1720s and in Futa Toro on the Senegal River in the 1770s. Their leaders denounced rulers who taxed Muslims unjustly, enslaved them or mixed Islam with older rites, and called for government by Islamic law.

Usman dan Fodio and Sokoto

The most influential reformer, Usman dan Fodio, a scholar of the Qadiriyya Sufi order, preached for decades in the Hausa state of Gobir. When Gobir's king turned against his community, Usman led his followers away in 1804, in imitation of the Prophet's flight from Mecca, and declared jihad. Within a few years his forces had overthrown most of the Hausa kings and replaced them with emirs. The result was the Sokoto Caliphate, the largest state in West Africa in the nineteenth century, a federation of some thirty emirates, under a caliph at Sokoto. Usman's son Muhammad Bello and his brother Abdullahi shared the work of government.

The caliphate brought a great expansion of Islamic learning. Its leaders wrote hundreds of works in Arabic, Fulfulde and Hausa. Usman's daughter Nana Asma'u was a poet and scholar in all three languages, and she organized a network of women teachers who traveled to instruct rural women, often using her poems as lessons. The caliphate had a darker side as well. Its wars, and later raids on non-Muslim peoples to the south, produced vast numbers of captives, and by the late nineteenth century it held one of the largest enslaved populations in the world.

A debate by letter

Not every Muslim accepted the jihad's claims. When Sokoto's forces attacked Bornu around 1808, Bornu's defense was organized by a scholar, Muhammad al-Amin al-Kanemi, who also took up his pen. In letters to the Sokoto leaders, al-Kanemi argued that Bornu's people were Muslims who could not lawfully be attacked. Muhammad Bello replied that Bornu's rulers tolerated practices that amounted to unbelief.

Masina and Umar Tal

In the Inland Niger Delta, a Fulbe scholar known as Seku Amadu founded the state of Masina around 1818, with its capital at Hamdallahi. Farther west, Umar Tal, a scholar from Futa Toro, led the Tijaniyya Sufi order in West Africa. From 1852 he waged jihad across the upper Senegal and Niger, clashing with the French, conquering the Bambara kingdom of Segu in 1861 and, controversially, the Muslim state of Masina in 1862.

Samori and the European conquest

In the 1870s and 1880s a Malinke trader and soldier, Samori Ture, built a new empire in the savanna of what is now Guinea and Ivory Coast. Facing the French, Samori set up workshops where smiths repaired and copied European rifles, bought modern guns through Sierra Leone and drilled his army in new tactics. When pressed, he moved his whole state eastward, leaving scorched land behind. He was captured in 1898 and died in exile in Gabon in 1900.

By then European armies held a decisive advantage. Quinine helped more Europeans survive malaria, steamboats carried troops up rivers, and the machine gun let small forces destroy much larger ones. In 1898 the English writer Hilaire Belloc captured the imbalance in a satirical poem, The Modern Traveller: "Whatever happens, we have got / The Maxim Gun, and they have not." In 1903 Britain conquered the Sokoto Caliphate, and by then nearly all of West Africa, apart from Liberia, was under European rule.

Worked example: Bello and al-Kanemi on legitimate war

The letters between Muhammad Bello and al-Kanemi raise a question that every tradition of law faces: who decides when it is right to make war on one's neighbors?

Bello's case ran like this. Islamic law permits jihad against unbelievers and against Muslims who abandon the faith. Bornu's rulers, he said, consulted spirits, made sacrifices at sacred sites and helped the Hausa kings against the reformers. Such acts, in his view, placed them outside Islam. Al-Kanemi answered that sinful practices do not make a Muslim an unbeliever. If they did, he argued in effect, no Muslim land anywhere would be safe, since every community has its faults. The remedy for error was teaching and correction, not war.

Both men accepted the same body of law. Their dispute turned on a definition, who counts as a Muslim, and on who holds the authority to apply it. Al-Kanemi's point echoes a worry found in many traditions: a power to declare others outside the community can be stretched to justify almost any attack. Bello's reply reflects an equally old conviction, that rulers who betray the law their people profess cannot claim its protection. Historians still debate how far each man was moved by politics as well as principle. Al-Kanemi was defending his own power; Bello was defending a revolution. Weighing the arguments on their merits while noticing the interests behind them is the double task that any political debate demands.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Usman dan Fodio's withdrawal from Gobir in 1804 imitate?
2. What did the Sokoto Caliphate become in the nineteenth century?
3. What did Nana Asma'u organize?
4. What did al-Kanemi argue in letters to Sokoto's leaders?
5. What did Seku Amadu found around 1818?
6. Which Sufi order did Umar Tal lead in West Africa?
7. What did Samori Ture do to arm his forces?
8. What happened to the Sokoto Caliphate in 1903?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia