Skip to main content

Every June for more than three centuries, people from all over Iceland rode for days across lava fields and rivers to a grassy rift valley in the southwest. There they traded, arranged marriages and settled their quarrels by law. The gathering was the Althing, and it ran a society with no king, no army and no police.

Assemblies of free men

Across the Norse world, free men met at assemblies called things. The word survives in place names such as Tingwall in Shetland and Tynwald on the Isle of Man. Iceland took the idea furthest, because it had no king at all.

How the Althing worked

The settlers set up a general assembly around 930, at Thingvellir, the "assembly plains," and it met for about two weeks each summer. Power rested with chieftains called goðar, at first 36 and later 39 of them, who sat in the Law Council, the body that made and amended law. A goði was not a lord of territory. Each free farmer attached himself to a chieftain of his choice, and farmers could switch to another chieftain if they were unhappy, which pushed chieftains to look after their followers.

At first the law was not written. Instead an elected official, the lawspeaker, held it in memory. From a spot called the Law Rock, he recited a third of the law each year, so that over his three-year term the whole of it was heard aloud, and he advised anyone who asked what the law said. The laws began to be written down in the winter of 1117 to 1118, and the collection that survives is known as Grágás, "Grey Goose."

Disputes went to courts, one for each of Iceland's four quarters, where panels of farmers named by the chieftains heard cases. Around 1005 a Fifth Court was added, an appeals court ruling by majority, to break the deadlocks that arose when the quarter courts required near unanimity.

Enforcing the law without a state

Here is the strange part. The Althing could judge, but it had no officers to carry out its judgments. The winning party, with kin and allies, had to enforce the verdict, which meant that a person with few friends could win in court and still get nothing. Most penalties were compensation payments, set by the rank of the victim and the seriousness of the wrong. Serious offenses brought outlawry. Lesser outlawry meant three years of exile. Full outlawry meant that anyone could kill the outlaw without penalty, and that anyone who sheltered or fed him broke the law.

Admirers, from medieval Icelanders to modern economists and political theorists, have seen in this system an impressive achievement: a society that replaced endless blood feud with negotiation, law and compensation, and that kept power spread among many chieftains and the farmers who could leave them. Its most famous decision, the adoption of Christianity around 1000, came by arbitration rather than by battle. Critics point to its limits. Women could not be chieftains or serve as judges, and they brought cases through male relatives. Slaves had no standing at all. And because enforcement depended on private strength, justice favored the well connected.

The end of the Commonwealth

Over time, power concentrated in a few great families who gathered many chieftaincies into their hands. In the 1200s their rivalries turned into near civil war, a period named for the leading Sturlung family, and the Norwegian king encouraged the conflict to extend his influence. Exhausted, Icelanders accepted Norway's king in 1262 to 1264, ending the independent Commonwealth. The Althing continued as a court and assembly under royal rule. It is often called the world's oldest parliament, but the claim is contested: it was abolished in 1800 and restored in 1845, so the Isle of Man's Tynwald claims the title of oldest continuous parliament instead.

Worked example: one law, one peace

By the late 990s Iceland was split. Missionaries sent by the Norwegian king Olaf Tryggvason had won converts, and the king was pressing the Icelanders hard. At the Althing of 1000, or perhaps 999, Christians and pagans came armed and threatened to declare themselves under separate laws, which would have meant two societies on one island.

Instead, both sides agreed to let the lawspeaker, Thorgeir, decide. He was himself a pagan. According to Ari Thorgilsson, writing about 120 years later, Thorgeir lay down under his cloak for a day and a night without speaking. Then he went to the Law Rock and argued that if the law were divided, the peace would be divided too. He ruled that all Icelanders would be baptized, but that people could still sacrifice to the old gods in private, eat horse meat and expose unwanted infants. These allowances were dropped a few years later.

Ari was a Christian priest, and his account may smooth over pressure and bargaining we cannot see. Still, the episode shows what the Althing was for. A saga phrase captures the ideal: með lögum skal land byggja, "with law shall the land be built." Faced with a conflict that could have ended in bloodshed, Icelanders chose a shared decision and a compromise that let each side keep something. Democratic societies still rely on that method when they disagree deeply.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. When and where was the Althing founded?
2. What did the lawspeaker do each year?
3. How were farmers bound to their chieftains?
4. Who had to enforce a court's judgment in Commonwealth Iceland?
5. What did full outlawry mean?
6. What was the Fifth Court?
7. How did the Icelandic Commonwealth end?
8. Why is the Althing's claim to be the oldest continuous parliament disputed?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia