The Geneva accords left two states, each claiming to be the true Vietnam. The nine years that followed decided whether the division would last, and they produced most of the problems that later drew the United States into war.
The great migration
The accords allowed civilians three hundred days to move between the zones. Close to a million people moved from north to south, most of them Catholics. Far fewer moved north, mostly Viet Minh fighters and their families, while many southern communist cadres stayed behind and hid their weapons, expecting the elections of 1956 to reunify the country.
Ngo Dinh Diem
Ngo Dinh Diem was a Catholic from a mandarin family who had served the Hue court and then refused to work with either the French or the Viet Minh. Bao Dai appointed him prime minister in 1954, and few expected him to last. Yet Diem defeated the private armies of the religious sects and of the Binh Xuyen, a crime syndicate that had controlled the Saigon police, and in October 1955 he held a referendum to depose Bao Dai. Diem's 1955 referendum was openly rigged: he claimed 98 percent of the vote, and in Saigon the ballots counted for him outnumbered registered voters. He then proclaimed the Republic of Vietnam with himself as president.
No elections
The reunification elections promised for 1956 never took place. Diem refused to hold the 1956 elections, and the United States supported his refusal. Diem argued that his government had never signed the accords and that no free vote was possible in the communist north. American officials privately feared that Ho Chi Minh, a national hero to many, would win. Both points had force, and historians still weigh them differently.
Diem's state
Diem's admirers saw a determined nationalist with his own vision of modernization, drawn from a Catholic philosophy called personalism, who refused to be an American puppet. His critics saw an autocrat who governed through his family. His brother Ngo Dinh Nhu ran a secret political party and the security services. A campaign against former Viet Minh in the south jailed and killed thousands, including noncommunist nationalists, and a 1959 law set up special military courts that could sentence opponents to death. Recent historians such as Edward Miller stress that Diem and his American backers often disagreed about what nation building meant, and that he was never a simple client.
Hanoi chooses war
Southern cadres being hunted down by Diem's police begged for help, and the party leadership in Hanoi debated how far to back armed struggle. Le Duan, who had led the party in the south and became party first secretary in 1960, pressed for action. In January 1959 the party's Resolution 15 approved armed struggle in the south. In December 1960 the National Liberation Front was founded to lead the southern insurgency. It welcomed noncommunists and presented itself as a southern movement, but it was directed by the party in Hanoi. Its opponents called its fighters the Viet Cong, short for Vietnamese communists.
Advisers and hamlets
President John F. Kennedy expanded American support. The number of American military advisers grew from under a thousand to about sixteen thousand by the end of 1963. The Strategic Hamlet Program tried to separate peasants from the guerrillas by moving them into fortified villages. In practice many villagers resented being forced to leave ancestral land, and the insurgents found ways in. At the battle of Ap Bac in January 1963, a small guerrilla force mauled a much larger South Vietnamese unit with American advisers, and American reporters began to doubt the official optimism.
The end of Diem
In 1963 a wave of Buddhist protest, described below, turned Washington against Diem. American officials let a group of South Vietnamese generals know that the United States would not stand in their way. Diem's rule ended in a coup by his own generals on 1 November 1963, and the next day he and Nhu were killed.
Worked example: the Buddhist crisis of 1963
In May 1963 officials in Hue banned the display of Buddhist flags on the Buddha's birthday, shortly after Catholic flags had flown at a celebration for Diem's brother, the archbishop of Hue. When crowds protested, government forces fired, and several people died. The incident tapped old grievances. Buddhists were the majority, yet Catholics held a large share of senior posts and enjoyed favor in land and promotion. Protests spread. In June the monk Thich Quang Duc burned himself to death at a Saigon intersection, and a photograph of his still, upright body in flames was printed around the world. In August, forces loyal to Nhu raided pagodas across the country and arrested hundreds of monks.
What does the crisis show? First, the war was never only about communism. A government that many of its own citizens saw as serving a minority could not easily ask them to die for it, however much aid it received. Second, outside backers have limited control over a client that depends on them. Third, removing a leader is easier than replacing him. The coup was followed by a string of short-lived military governments, and the insurgency grew in the confusion.
