A union of republics
When the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics was founded at the end of 1922, its name contained no geography at all. It was meant to be a union that any socialist republic in the world could one day join. The founding members were Russia, Ukraine, Belarus and a Transcaucasian federation of Georgia, Armenia and Azerbaijan; Central Asian republics were added later in the 1920s and 1930s. The constitution of 1924 described a federation of equal union republics, and it gave each of them the formal right to leave the union. Real power ran through a single, centralized Communist Party, and party discipline bound the leaders of every republic to decisions made in Moscow.
Still, the early Soviet state took nationality seriously in a way the old empire never had. Lenin feared that Russian chauvinism would drive the smaller peoples into the arms of nationalists, so the party adopted a policy called korenizatsiia, or indigenization: the promotion of local languages and of local people into official posts. Schools, newspapers and courts began working in Ukrainian, Belarusian, Tatar, Uzbek and dozens of other languages. The historian Terry Martin has described the result as an empire that, unusually, sponsored the national identities of its non-Russian subjects, while still denying them any real political independence.
The party-state
On paper, the country was governed by elected councils, the soviets. In practice, decisions were made in the party's small leading body, the Politburo, and carried out through a vast apparatus of party committees. In 1922 Joseph Stalin became general secretary, a post that sounded clerical but controlled appointments. The key tool was the nomenklatura: party lists of important posts together with the people approved to fill them. Whoever controlled those lists controlled careers, and over time the officials who owed their jobs to the apparatus formed a new ruling class.
Lenin suffered a series of strokes and died in January 1924. Against the wishes of his widow, Nadezhda Krupskaya, his body was embalmed and put on public display in a mausoleum on Red Square, and Petrograd was renamed Leningrad. A party that rejected religion built something close to a cult of relics around its founder.
Life under NEP
The economy of the 1920s was a mixture. The state held the "commanding heights": banks, heavy industry, railways and foreign trade. Peasants farmed their own plots and sold surplus grain, and small shops, cafes and workshops reopened. The Nepmen, private traders and small businessmen who prospered under NEP, became figures of envy and contempt in cartoons and plays, and the police kept a close eye on them. The arrangement was fragile. In 1923 came the scissors crisis, a widening gap between rising industrial prices and falling farm prices, named for the way the two lines on a graph opened like the blades of scissors. Peasants who could buy little with their grain had less reason to sell it.
The grain crisis and the end of NEP
In the winter of 1927 to 1928, state grain purchases fell far short of plan. Prices offered by the state were low, there were few manufactured goods to buy, and a war scare in 1927 made peasants cautious. Stalin traveled to Siberia in January 1928 and ordered emergency grain seizures, backed by criminal charges for hoarding. Nikolai Bukharin, the leading defender of NEP, warned that coercion would wreck the alliance between workers and peasants. He was condemned as the leader of a "Right deviation" and lost his posts in 1929.
The left opposition had already been defeated. Trotsky was expelled from the party in 1927, sent to internal exile in Kazakhstan in 1928, and deported from the Soviet Union in 1929. By the end of that year, Stalin had no serious rival left in the leadership.
Worked example: the Shakhty trial
In March 1928 the secret police announced that they had uncovered a conspiracy among mining engineers in the Shakhty district of the Donbas coalfield. Fifty three defendants, including several German technicians, were tried in Moscow that summer in the grand hall of the House of Unions, with newsreel cameras and foreign journalists present. They were charged with wrecking, the deliberate sabotage of industry on behalf of former owners and foreign powers. Many confessed. Eleven were sentenced to death, and five of them were shot.
How should a historian read such a trial? Start with the evidence. The confessions were extracted under pressure, some defendants withdrew them in court, and no independent defense was possible. Then ask what the trial did. It offered the public a simple explanation for accidents and shortages in the mines: not bad planning, but enemies. It warned the "bourgeois specialists" trained before 1917 that their skills would not protect them. And it set a pattern. Over the next decade, show trials with scripted confessions became a central ritual of Soviet politics.
The trial also shows something about the value of persons. When a verdict is settled before the hearing begins, the accused are no longer treated as individuals whose guilt must be proven. They become props in a lesson meant for others. That is why fair procedure is not a technicality: it is the means by which a state recognizes that each person before it counts.
