Skip to main content

The Tokugawa world had edges. To the north lay the Ainu of Ezo, to the south the kingdom of Ryukyu, and beyond them European empires whose ships appeared more often each decade. How the shogunate handled these edges shaped both its strength and its fall.

The Ainu and the north

The Matsumae domain on the southern tip of Ezo, today's Hokkaido, held a monopoly on trade with the Ainu, who lived by hunting, fishing and trading. Matsumae steadily turned the terms of exchange against them, giving less rice for more salmon and furs. In 1669 Shakushain, an Ainu chief, led a war against Matsumae, and his followers killed hundreds of Japanese traders and sailors. Matsumae, backed by the shogunate, gained the upper hand, and Shakushain was murdered at a banquet held to make peace. Afterward Matsumae tightened its control, and merchants contracted to run fisheries often treated Ainu workers as forced labor. A later revolt in 1789 was crushed in the same way.

Ryukyu between two masters

In 1609 the Satsuma domain invaded the kingdom of Ryukyu and made it a dependency, but it kept the Ryukyu king on his throne and allowed him to keep sending tribute to China. Satsuma preserved Ryukyu's tribute ties with China because the trade that came with them was profitable, and Japan had no direct official relations with the Chinese court. Satsuma even hid its control from Chinese envoys. Ryukyu sent missions to Edo, where their foreign dress displayed the shogun's prestige over a kingdom beyond Japan. The arrangement suited everyone except perhaps the Ryukyuans, who served two masters at once.

Ships from the north and west

From the late eighteenth century Russia pushed into the North Pacific. In 1792 the Russian officer Adam Laxman sailed to Ezo bringing home Daikokuya Kodayu, a Japanese castaway who had spent nearly ten years in Russia and met Empress Catherine the Great. Laxman was given a permit to call at Nagasaki, but when a Russian envoy arrived there in 1804 he was kept waiting for half a year and then refused. His frustrated officers later raided Japanese posts in the north.

In 1808 the British warship Phaeton sailed into Nagasaki under a Dutch flag and seized Dutch hostages, threatening the city until it received food and water. Britain and the Netherlands were at war, and the Phaeton was hunting Dutch ships. The Nagasaki magistrate, shamed that he could not stop it, took his own life. The incident showed how weak Japan's coastal defenses had become.

Maps, secrets and the Siebold affair

Knowledge of the country itself was growing. Ino Tadataka, a retired merchant who took up astronomy around the age of fifty, surveyed the coasts of Japan on foot from 1800 to 1816, and his team completed a map of remarkable accuracy after his death. Such maps were state secrets. The German doctor Philipp Franz von Siebold, who taught Western medicine at the Dutch post, collected Japanese objects and information. In 1828 officials discovered that he had obtained copies of official maps, and the shogunate astronomer Takahashi Kageyasu, who had given them to him, died in prison. Siebold was expelled. The shogunate wanted Western knowledge, but on its own terms.

The end

In 1853 American warships under Matthew Perry forced the issue, and within fifteen years the shogunate faced foreign treaties, inflation, assassinations and a coalition of domains rallying around the emperor. The commercial treaties of 1858 were signed without the emperor's approval, which allowed the shogunate's enemies to brand it disloyal to the throne it claimed to serve. The fifteenth shogun, Tokugawa Yoshinobu, tried to save what he could. In late 1867 Yoshinobu handed governing authority back to the emperor, hoping to lead a council of lords under the throne. His enemies instead declared the shogunate abolished, and a brief civil war ended Tokugawa rule. Yoshinobu lived quietly for more than four decades, taking up photography.

Worked example: weighing the Tokugawa peace

How should the era be judged? For many years Meiji reformers and later historians described it as a feudal, closed society that held Japan back, a dark age that made modernization necessary. In that view, the shogunate froze people in hereditary ranks, crushed protest and kept Japan ignorant of the world.

Many historians now stress a different set of facts. From the end of the Shimabara Rebellion in 1638 until the 1860s, Japan fought no wars, an unusual achievement for a large society. Roads, markets, banking practices and widespread schooling all developed under Tokugawa rule, giving the Meiji state a literate, organized population to build on. Foreign relations were managed, not absent.

A fair judgment holds both sides. The peace was real and it saved countless lives. It was also bought with the persecution of Christians, the dispossession of the Ainu, rigid discrimination against outcastes and a political system that gave ordinary people no rights, only duties and petitions. Weighing it means asking a question that applies far beyond Japan: how much security is worth how much freedom, and who gets to decide?

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Who led the Ainu war against Matsumae in 1669?
2. How did Shakushain die?
3. Why did Satsuma let Ryukyu keep sending tribute to China?
4. Whom did Adam Laxman bring to Japan in 1792?
5. What did the Phaeton do at Nagasaki in 1808?
6. What did Ino Tadataka do?
7. What happened to Takahashi Kageyasu after the Siebold affair?
8. What did Tokugawa Yoshinobu do in late 1867?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia