Wars are fought by states, and in the summer of 1936 neither side had one that worked. How each built its war machine, and at what cost to its own supporters, decided much of the result.
Franco takes command
The rebel generals first ruled through a committee, the National Defense Junta at Burgos. Franco had clear advantages over his rivals: he commanded the Army of Africa, the only force winning steadily, and he controlled the channels of German and Italian aid. In late September 1936 he turned aside from the advance on Madrid to relieve the besieged Alcázar fortress in Toledo, a delay that may have cost him the capital but made him a hero in the rebel press. On 29 September the generals named him supreme commander, and on 1 October 1936 Franco took office as head of state. His side called itself the Nationalists. Mola, his only serious rival, died in a plane crash in June 1937.
One party, one Church
The Nationalist coalition included Falangists, Carlists, monarchists loyal to Alfonso XIII's son, and conservative Catholics. In April 1937 Franco ended their quarrels from above. The Decree of Unification merged the Falange and the Carlists into a single party under his own leadership. The Falange's founder, José Antonio, had been executed in a Republican prison in Alicante in November 1936, and Manuel Hedilla, the Falangist leader who resisted the merger, was arrested and sentenced to death, though the sentence was commuted. The new state took the Falange's blue shirts and raised-arm salute, the Carlists' red berets and the Church's blessing.
Most of the Spanish hierarchy saw the war as a defense of the faith after the killing of clergy. Bishops described it as a crusade, and in July 1937 they addressed a collective letter supporting the Nationalist cause to the bishops of the world. The Basque Nationalist Party, Catholic and conservative, nonetheless sided with the Republic, which had granted Basque autonomy in October 1936, and Nationalist forces executed a number of Basque priests. After Guernica, Bilbao fell in June 1937, and by October the whole northern strip, with its mines and factories, was in Nationalist hands.
The Republic's dilemma
The Republican side was far more divided. In September 1936 the Socialist Largo Caballero formed a government of the left, and in November four anarchists entered it as ministers, a startling step for a movement that rejected the state. One of them, Federica Montseny, became Spain's first woman cabinet minister, in charge of health. The militias were slowly folded into a new Popular Army with ranks and discipline.
Beneath this lay a hard argument. The Communists, many Socialists and the Republican parties held that winning the war came first, and that the revolution must wait; they wanted a single army, a state monopoly of force and the support of small farmers, shopkeepers and the foreign democracies. The anarchists and the anti-Stalinist Marxists of the POUM replied that the revolution was what gave workers a reason to fight, and that crushing it would kill the Republic's spirit.
The May Days
The argument exploded in Barcelona in May 1937. When government police tried to take over the city's telephone exchange, held by the CNT since July, fighting broke out between anarchists and the POUM on one side and government forces and Communists on the other. Several hundred people died before a truce. Largo Caballero soon fell, and the Socialist Juan Negrín became prime minister in May 1937. In June the POUM was outlawed, and its leader Andreu Nin was arrested and murdered by Soviet agents. In August troops dissolved the anarchist-led Council of Aragon and broke up many of its collectives.
Worked example: Orwell in Barcelona
The English writer George Orwell came to Spain in December 1936 and joined the militia of the POUM. In his book Homage to Catalonia, published in 1938, he remembered the Barcelona of that winter as a city run by its workers, with collectivized cafés and comradely forms of address. Returning on leave in late April 1937, he found the rich back in the restaurants and the revolutionary mood gone. He was on the rooftops during the May fighting, was shot through the throat at the front soon afterward, and escaped from Spain as the POUM was hunted down.
Orwell's account remains one of the most widely read books on the war, and it makes a powerful case that the Communists betrayed a genuine revolution. Read with a historian's care, though, it is one witness from one corner. Defenders of Negrín's course, including many historians, argue that the revolution had produced disorder, disrupted the economy and frightened off the democracies whose help the Republic desperately needed, and that a regular army was its only chance of survival. Critics answer that the Republic also lost the enthusiasm of its most committed supporters. Both camps can agree on one point: the persecution of the POUM, including the torture and murder of prisoners, was a crime that no claim of military need can excuse.
