Skip to main content

The Spanish monarchy did not fall to a revolution or a battle. It fell to an election for town councils.

Ballots and a departure

On 12 April 1931 Spain held municipal elections that both sides treated as a vote on the crown. Monarchist candidates won many rural seats, where the caciques still held sway, but republican and socialist candidates swept most of the provincial capitals and large cities. Two days later crowds celebrated in the streets, and the Second Republic was proclaimed on 14 April. Alfonso XIII left Spain without formally abdicating, saying he wished to avoid bloodshed. A provisional government led by Niceto Alcalá-Zamora, a Catholic conservative who had become a republican, took office.

The new regime quickly faced violence. In May 1931, after an incident at a monarchist club inflamed a crowd in Madrid, churches and convents were set on fire in Madrid and several southern cities while the government hesitated to call out troops. Many Catholics who might have accepted the Republic concluded that it would not protect them.

The Constitution of 1931

A constituent parliament, elected in June, produced a new constitution in December 1931. It defined Spain as a democratic republic of workers of every class, created a single-chamber parliament, allowed divorce and renounced war as an instrument of national policy. It also separated church and state, ended state salaries for the clergy and placed tight limits on religious orders. Under these rules the Jesuits were dissolved in 1932, and a 1933 law barred religious orders from teaching. Defenders saw these steps as overdue freedom from clerical power. Critics, including some republicans, argued that they turned millions of believing Catholics into enemies of the regime at its birth.

Votes for women

The most famous debate concerned women's suffrage. Women could already be elected to the constituent parliament, and three were. Clara Campoamor of the Radical Party argued that a republic could not deny half its citizens the vote. Victoria Kent, a fellow republican lawyer, argued for delay, fearing that women's votes would be swayed by priests. On 1 October 1931 the parliament approved equal suffrage, and women voted in a national election for the first time in November 1933.

Army, regions and schools

Manuel Azaña, minister of war and from October 1931 prime minister, believed the army was swollen and politically dangerous. He offered officers early retirement on full pay to shrink the bloated officer corps, and he closed the General Military Academy at Zaragoza, whose director was General Francisco Franco. Many officers who stayed felt insulted. In September 1932 parliament approved a statute of autonomy for Catalonia, with its own government, the Generalitat. The Republic also built thousands of new schools and sent traveling "pedagogical missions," carrying books, films and plays, to remote villages.

Land and labor reform

Francisco Largo Caballero, the Socialist labor minister, introduced mixed juries of workers and employers to settle wages, and a law requiring landowners to hire laborers from their own municipality before bringing in outsiders. The Agrarian Reform Law of September 1932 set out to redistribute large estates, but it was complicated, poorly funded and slow. By the end of 1933 only a few thousand families had been settled on new land. Landowners thought the reform went too far; laborers felt cheated by how little it delivered.

Threats from right and left

In August 1932 General José Sanjurjo led a failed military rising in Seville, which was quickly put down. The anarchists of the CNT, who regarded the Republic as one more bourgeois state, staged a series of local insurrections. One, in January 1933, ended in tragedy at the Andalusian village of Casas Viejas, where government Assault Guards killed about twenty villagers, some shot after they had been taken prisoner. The scandal badly damaged Azaña's government.

Worked example: Campoamor and Kent

The suffrage debate of 1931 shows how hard it is to weigh principle against strategy. Campoamor's case was a matter of principle: rights belong to persons, not only to those expected to vote the right way. She warned that a republic that excluded women would rest on the same kind of exclusion it claimed to reject. Kent did not deny that women deserved equality. Her case was strategic. The Republic was young, the Church was hostile, and most Spanish women had been schooled by nuns. Grant the vote later, she urged, once the Republic had secured itself.

The measure passed with votes from the Socialists and parts of the right, while many left republicans opposed it. When the right won the 1933 election, some blamed women voters, but historians point mainly to other causes, above all the division of the left and anarchist abstention. Campoamor lost her seat and later wrote about the episode in exile. The case is a test of democratic principle: either citizens are trusted with the vote even when their choices are feared, or the franchise becomes a tool of whoever happens to hold power.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Where did republican candidates win in the municipal elections of April 1931?
2. How did Alfonso XIII leave the throne in 1931?
3. What did the Constitution of 1931 say about war?
4. When did Spanish women first vote in a national election?
5. How did Azaña try to shrink the officer corps?
6. What did Catalonia receive in September 1932?
7. Who led the failed military rising in Seville in August 1932?
8. What happened at Casas Viejas in January 1933?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia