Skip to main content

The Seljuk age was a time of fierce argument about religion. Sunni scholars debated with each other as well as with Shia rivals; mystics questioned whether book learning brought anyone closer to God; and a small, determined Ismaili movement defied the sultans from mountain castles. Each of these struggles left marks that lasted long after the Seljuks.

The Nizamiyya colleges

Nizam al-Mulk founded a network of colleges, called madrasas, in major cities. The most famous, the Nizamiyya of Baghdad, opened in 1067. Others stood in Nishapur, Isfahan, Merv and elsewhere. Each was paid for by an endowment that covered the salaries of teachers and stipends for students. The Nizamiyya colleges mainly taught Shafi'i law and Ash'ari theology, the legal school and the theology the vizier favored.

It is often said that Nizam al-Mulk invented the madrasa. He did not. Madrasas already existed in Khurasan before the Nizamiyya, and teaching had long taken place in mosques and private homes. What Nizam did was found colleges on a grand scale, tie them to his own patronage and give their graduates a path into government service. The colleges trained judges, preachers and officials who shared a Sunni outlook, which strengthened the state while also strengthening the vizier's network of loyal men.

Al-Ghazali's crisis

The most famous teacher at the Baghdad Nizamiyya was Abu Hamid al-Ghazali, a jurist and theologian from Tus, appointed in 1091. He was brilliant, admired and well paid. Then, in 1095, al-Ghazali suffered a crisis and left his post. By his own account he lost the ability to speak and eat, and came to believe that his teaching served fame rather than God. He gave away his wealth, left Baghdad and spent years traveling and living as a Sufi, a Muslim mystic, in Damascus, Jerusalem and elsewhere.

Years later he described this journey in a short book, Deliverance from Error, an account of his own search for certainty. He tells how he examined the claims of theologians, philosophers, Ismailis and Sufis, and how he found certainty at last in the direct experience of the mystics. He returned to teaching in Nishapur in 1106 and died in Tus in 1111. His great work, the Revival of the Religious Sciences, tried to join careful law with inner devotion, and it shaped Sunni piety for centuries.

Persian literature also flourished under Seljuk patronage. Court poets such as Mu'izzi, chief poet to Malikshah and later to Sanjar, wrote elaborate praise poems for the sultans. The quatrains later attached to the name of Omar Khayyam, wry and skeptical about fate and the shortness of life, belong to the same world, although scholars doubt that he wrote many of the poems credited to him. Persian, not Turkish, was the language in which the Seljuk court chose to be praised.

Hasan-i Sabbah and Alamut

The Ismailis were a branch of Shia Islam whose leaders, the imams, had become the Fatimid caliphs of Cairo. In Iran, an Ismaili missionary named Hasan-i Sabbah built a network of followers among townspeople and villagers who resented Turkish rule. In 1090, after his supporters had quietly converted the garrison, Hasan-i Sabbah took the castle of Alamut in the Alborz mountains of northern Iran without a battle. It became the center of a chain of mountain fortresses.

When the Fatimid caliph al-Mustansir died in 1094, his sons Nizar and al-Musta'li both claimed to succeed him. The army in Cairo backed al-Musta'li, and Nizar was killed. Hasan backed Nizar's line, so a dispute over the Fatimid succession split the Ismailis. Hasan's followers, the Nizaris, now stood alone against both Cairo and the Seljuks.

Outnumbered, the Nizaris used a weapon suited to the weak: the killing of carefully chosen commanders, judges and officials, usually by devoted volunteers who expected to die. The fear this spread was out of all proportion to the number of victims. Seljuk armies besieged the castles again and again but never destroyed the network. It lasted until the Mongols arrived in the 1250s.

Worked example: what is in a name?

The English word assassin comes from this conflict. Enemies of the Nizaris, in Syria and elsewhere, called them hashishiyya, users of hashish, a term of abuse meaning roughly "riffraff." So the word assassin comes from an insult used by the Ismailis' enemies, not from anything the Nizaris called themselves. European crusaders picked up the name, and Marco Polo later told a tale of young men drugged and shown a garden of paradise to make them obedient killers.

Test the story. Is there any evidence from Nizari writings that they used drugs? No. Who told it? Hostile Muslim writers and Europeans who never visited Alamut. Why does Nizari evidence matter so much, and why is so little of it left? When the Mongols took Alamut, the historian Juvayni examined the castle's famous library and burned most of it, keeping a few works he judged useful. Most surviving accounts of the Nizaris were therefore written by their enemies. The modern historian Farhad Daftary and others have rebuilt a fuller picture from scattered Ismaili texts, showing a community with scholars, books and beliefs, not merely a band of killers.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did the Nizamiyya colleges mainly teach?
2. Did Nizam al-Mulk invent the madrasa?
3. What did al-Ghazali do in 1095?
4. What is al-Ghazali's Deliverance from Error?
5. What did Hasan-i Sabbah take in 1090?
6. What split the Ismailis in 1094?
7. Where does the English word assassin come from?
8. What happened to the library of Alamut?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia