Skip to main content

African rulers did not face conquest as passive victims or as a single bloc. They weighed threats, rivals and opportunities, and chose among war, negotiation, alliance and retreat, often trying several in turn. Their choices shaped where and how colonial rule took hold.

How historians frame resistance

Older imperial histories described "pacification," as if Africans had merely been calmed. In the 1960s the historian Terence Ranger, writing as many African states became independent, argued that early resistance movements were forerunners of later nationalism, linking the armed risings of the 1890s to the independence struggles of his own day. Later historians have warned that the categories of "resister" and "collaborator" are too simple. A king who fought one power might ally with another, and the same leader might negotiate one year and fight the next.

War

Some states fought long and hard. In Sudan, Muhammad Ahmad proclaimed himself the Mahdi, the expected redeemer, in 1881, and built a state that drove out Egyptian rule and held power until 1898. In West Africa, the kingdom of Dahomey under King Béhanzin fought the French from 1890. A French force led by Colonel Alfred-Amédée Dodds, himself born in Senegal, took the capital Abomey in 1892. Béhanzin kept fighting until 1894, when he surrendered and was exiled to Martinique in the Caribbean.

In German East Africa, the Hehe under their chief Mkwawa won a striking victory. At Lugalo in 1891 the Hehe destroyed a German column, killing its commander and most of his men. Mkwawa held out for years of guerrilla war and shot himself in 1898 to avoid capture. His head was cut off and sent to Germany, and the matter became so symbolic that Article 246 of the Treaty of Versailles ordered Germany to hand over Mkwawa's skull. A skull was returned only in 1954.

Diplomacy

Other leaders fought with words. In 1895 three kings of the Tswana, Khama III, Sebele and Bathoen, traveled to Britain to oppose a plan to hand their lands to Cecil Rhodes's company. They addressed public meetings, won church support and met the colonial secretary, Joseph Chamberlain. Khama, Sebele and Bathoen persuaded Britain to keep their lands out of the British South Africa Company's control, though they gave up a strip for a railway. The protectorate of Bechuanaland, later Botswana, stayed under the Crown.

Rulers also played the powers against each other. Menelik of Ethiopia bought arms from France and Russia while negotiating with Italy, and Liberia leaned on American goodwill as Britain and France pressed on its borders. Small states sometimes invited a distant protector to keep out a nearer and more dangerous one, as the Tswana kings did. Such diplomacy rarely preserved full independence, but it could win better terms: land kept, kings retained, settlers held at bay.

Alliance

Some rulers sought advantage by joining the invaders. In Buganda, by Lake Victoria, a revolution in the late 1880s brought Christian chiefs to power. They allied with Britain, and Buganda's Christian chiefs helped the British conquer neighboring Bunyoro, their old rival, gaining land in return. Alliance was rarely simple loyalty. It was a calculation that a powerful outsider could be used against nearer enemies.

Rising after conquest

Many of the largest revolts came not at first contact but years later. Rulers who had accepted a treaty or a garrison often discovered only afterward what foreign rule meant in practice: taxes in cash, forced labor, seized cattle and land taken for settlers. The great risings in southern Africa in 1896, in German South West Africa in 1904 and in German East Africa in 1905 all followed that pattern. Historians therefore see resistance less as a single moment of defeat than as a long contest over the terms of rule.

Everyday refusal

Most people resisted without armies. They hid crops and cattle, worked slowly, deserted from labor gangs, and appealed to missionaries or courts. Moving across a colonial border was one of the commonest ways people evaded colonial demands, since a tax collector's power stopped at the line. Such acts left few monuments but constantly limited what colonial states could do.

Worked example: the risings of 1896 in Southern Rhodesia

By 1896 the lands Rhodes's company had seized were in crisis. Rinderpest was killing the herds, drought and locusts had hit the crops, and the company's police seized cattle and forced men into labor. Many of those police had been withdrawn for a failed raid on the Transvaal in the last days of 1895. In March 1896 the Ndebele rose; in June, to settlers' astonishment, many Shona communities rose too.

Spirit mediums, among them Nehanda and Kaguvi, helped give the risings purpose and coordination. Rhodes eventually walked into the Matopos hills to negotiate with Ndebele leaders, while Shona fighting continued into 1897 and was crushed with dynamite used against cave refuges. Nehanda and Kaguvi were hanged in 1898. Ranger's 1967 study of the risings stressed the mediums' role in uniting them; later historians argued that coordination was looser than he thought. Zimbabwe's guerrillas of the 1970s called their own war the second Chimurenga, a name that shows how memories of resistance became part of later politics.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Terence Ranger argue about early resistance movements?
2. What did Muhammad Ahmad proclaim in Sudan in 1881?
3. What happened to King Béhanzin of Dahomey after he surrendered in 1894?
4. What happened at Lugalo in 1891?
5. What did Article 246 of the Treaty of Versailles require of Germany?
6. What did Khama, Sebele and Bathoen achieve in Britain in 1895?
7. How did Buganda's Christian chiefs gain from alliance with Britain?
8. What was one of the commonest ways ordinary people evaded colonial demands?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia