Skip to main content

Thomas Hobbes was born in 1588, the year the Spanish Armada sailed against England. In 1640, fearing arrest as tensions rose before the civil wars, he fled to Paris, and there he wrote most of Leviathan, published in 1651. Its question was urgent. What could stop people who disagreed bitterly about God, property and power from killing one another?

Equal enough to fear each other

Hobbes starts from equality, though not a flattering kind. People differ in strength and cleverness, but not by enough for anyone to feel safe, because "the weakest has strength enough to kill the strongest, either by secret machination, or by confederacy with others." Hobbes thought people roughly equal because even the weakest can kill the strongest by cunning or by joining with others. When two people want the same thing and cannot both have it, they become enemies.

Three causes of quarrel

"So that in the nature of man," Hobbes wrote, "we find three principal causes of quarrel. First, competition; secondly, diffidence; thirdly, glory." Competition drives people to attack for gain, and glory drives them to attack over insults and reputation. Diffidence is the most modern part of the argument. By diffidence Hobbes meant distrust, which drives people to strike first for their own safety. Even people who want nothing but to be left alone have reason to attack first, because waiting may mean being attacked.

A condition, not a battle

Where there is no common power to keep everyone in awe, people are in "that condition which is called war; and such a war, as is of every man, against every man." Hobbes compared it to weather. Foul weather is not one shower but a tendency to rain over many days. For Hobbes, war is the known disposition to fight, even at moments when no one is fighting. In that condition there is no room for farming, trade, building, knowledge or arts, "and the life of man, solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short."

Hobbes pointed to his readers' own habits. Think of a man who travels armed and in company, who locks his doors when he sleeps and locks his chests even inside his own house, although there are laws and officers to protect him. What opinion of his fellow citizens does that show?

Rights, laws and the covenant

Hobbes separates the right of nature, the liberty each person has to use his own power to preserve his life, from the laws of nature, which are rules of reason. The first law tells us to seek peace where it can be had. The second tells us to be willing, when others are willing too, to give up our right to all things, "and be contented with so much liberty against other men, as he would allow other men against himself." Yet promises alone are fragile: "covenants, without the sword, are but words, and of no strength to secure a man at all."

So people covenant with one another to authorize a single representative to act for them all. Hobbes allowed that the sovereign could be either one person or an assembly, though he thought monarchy worked best. Crucially, the covenant is made among the subjects, not with the ruler. Because the sovereign was never a party to the covenant, Hobbes argued, the sovereign cannot breach it, and subjects cannot claim release on that ground.

Limits even Leviathan cannot cross

Hobbes was not simply an apologist for tyranny. People make the covenant to stay alive, so some rights cannot be given away. No one can surrender the right to resist those who come to kill, wound or imprison him, and so even a lawfully condemned criminal keeps the right to resist those who come to kill him. More striking still: "The obligation of subjects to the sovereign is understood to last as long, and no longer, than the power lasteth by which he is able to protect them." For Hobbes, subjects owe obedience only as long as the sovereign can actually protect them.

Critics reply that Hobbes mistook the conduct of people in civil war for human nature, and that an unchecked sovereign may itself be the greatest threat to life.

Worked example: the valley after the collapse

Imagine a river valley where the government has collapsed. Two farming families live on opposite banks. Neither wants a fight, but each knows the other has a rifle, and each knows a hungry winter is coming. Hobbes's analysis predicts trouble even without greed. Diffidence does the real damage: each family reasons that if the other raids first, it may lose everything, so striking first looks like self-defense. Notice too that the valley is at war in Hobbes's sense even on quiet days, because everyone is watching the far bank.

Suppose the families swear an oath to leave each other alone. Hobbes would say the promise is "but words": whoever keeps it while the other breaks it is ruined, and nothing stops a breach. What changes things is a third party with the power to punish. If both families authorize a council with armed constables, each can disarm without being a fool. Hobbes would add a warning and a limit. The council's power must be strong enough to keep order, but if it ever starts to kill the people it was made to protect, they keep the right to defend themselves.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Why did Hobbes think people were roughly equal by nature?
2. What did Hobbes mean by diffidence as a cause of quarrel?
3. How did Hobbes define war in the state of nature?
4. What everyday habit did Hobbes cite as evidence of distrust?
5. What form did Hobbes allow the sovereign to take?
6. Why, for Hobbes, can the sovereign not breach the covenant?
7. What right did Hobbes say even a condemned criminal keeps?
8. How long, for Hobbes, do subjects owe obedience to the sovereign?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia