Peter's reforms were not only decrees on paper. They were carried out on the bodies of laborers, on the habits of noble families and finally inside Peter's own household.
A capital built by force
The court and government moved to St Petersburg in stages from about 1712. Each year tens of thousands of conscripted peasants, soldiers and Swedish prisoners were sent to drain marshes, drive piles and raise buildings. Many died of disease, cold and hunger. Older accounts claimed huge death tolls, but the records are poor, and historians still give very different estimates. To speed construction, a decree of 1714 banned stone building elsewhere in Russia to draw stonemasons to the new capital. Nobles and merchants were ordered to build houses there whether they wished to live in a damp new city or not.
Changing the household
Peter wanted the elite to live differently, not just dress differently. A decree of 1718 introduced assemblies, mixed gatherings that noble women were required to attend alongside men, with conversation, cards and dancing. They broke the old seclusion of elite women in the terem. In 1712 he publicly married Catherine, a woman of Livonian peasant origin who had been taken captive in the war and had become his companion.
The tsarevich
Peter's son by his first marriage, Alexei, was born in 1690. He was intelligent and bookish but cool toward war, ships and the new capital, and he was close to clergy and to people who disliked the reforms. Peter wrote to him that he would rather have a worthy stranger as heir than a useless son. In 1716 Alexei fled to Vienna and the emperor Charles VI, who was married to the sister of Alexei's late wife. He was hidden for a time near Naples. The diplomat Peter Tolstoy found him and talked him into coming home with promises of pardon.
The pardon did not hold. Alexei was questioned, his friends were arrested and some were executed, and his mother's circle was punished. Under torture he admitted hoping for his father's death. A court of senators and officials condemned him, and in June 1718 he died in the Peter and Paul Fortress after torture, before the sentence was carried out. No one can say for certain how he died.
Succession by choice
The affair left Peter with a problem. His only surviving son, a child by Catherine, died in 1719. In 1722 a new law allowed the ruler to name any successor, without regard to birth order or even family. Peter then died on 28 January 1725, aged fifty-two, without naming anyone. A later story claims he wrote "Give everything to" and could not finish, but the tale may be invented. The law meant to make the succession secure left it open to whoever controlled the capital.
The verdict of historians
Russians argued about Peter for the next two centuries. In the 1840s the Slavophiles claimed that he had split the educated elite from the people, breaking the shared faith and customs of old Russia and creating a nobility that looked to Europe and treated peasants as foreigners. Their opponents, the Westernizers, hailed him as the man who brought Russia into the European family of nations.
Vasily Klyuchevsky, writing around 1900, argued that the reforms grew piecemeal out of the needs of war rather than from a master plan. He also judged that Peter tried to call up energy and initiative in a society he held in bondage, and that coercion and freedom pulled against each other in everything he did. More recent historians stress continuity: Westernizing had begun under Peter's father and under Golitsyn, and many reforms worked less well in practice than on paper.
The case for Peter is strong: Russia won its war, gained the Baltic, and built schools, a navy, an academy and an effective state. The case against him is strong too: the cost fell on peasants, recruits and laborers, serfdom deepened, and autocracy grew more powerful.
Worked example: the Bronze Horseman
In 1782 a great equestrian statue of Peter by the French sculptor Étienne Falconet was unveiled on Senate Square in St Petersburg. Peter rides a rearing horse on a vast granite rock dragged from the shore of the Gulf of Finland. The statue was Catherine II's commission, and its inscription, in Latin and Russian, reads "To Peter the First, Catherine the Second". A German-born empress who had taken the throne in a coup was placing herself in Peter's line.
Half a century later Alexander Pushkin gave the statue its popular name in his poem The Bronze Horseman (1833). The poem opens with Peter on an empty shore planning a city that would open a window on Europe, then turns to the flood of 1824 and a poor clerk, Evgeny, who loses the woman he loves. Maddened, he shakes his fist at the statue and imagines it galloping after him through the night streets.
Read the two works side by side. The statue makes an argument for greatness and inheritance. The poem accepts the greatness but asks what it cost the small person who had to live in the city the giant built. Monuments, like history books, take positions.
