Skip to main content

On 15 March 1848 a young poet, Sándor Petőfi, read his "National Song" to crowds in Pest, calling on Hungarians to choose between freedom and slavery. The same day students and writers printed a list of twelve demands, including a free press and a government responsible to parliament. They seized a printing press and published the Twelve Points without a censor's approval, a small act that announced a new era. Within weeks Hungary had its April Laws and its own ministry. But Hungary was itself a kingdom of many peoples, and the springtime of nations quickly became a contest among them.

Hungary and its neighbors

Hungarian liberals thought in terms of one political nation: everyone in the kingdom would be a free citizen, but the state, its parliament and its schools would be Hungarian. Hungarians, however, were well under half of the kingdom's population. Croats, Serbs, Romanians and Slovaks heard the promise of equal citizenship and feared rule by a Hungarian state that would not recognize them as nations.

The Croats moved first. Their governor, or ban, Josip Jelačić, broke with Budapest, and in September 1848 he crossed into Hungary with an army in the emperor's name. Hungarian forces stopped Jelačić at Pákozd at the end of the month. In the south, a Serbian assembly at Sremski Karlovci in May had already proclaimed a Serbian Vojvodina, a self-governing region within the monarchy, and fighting followed. In Transylvania a vast meeting of Romanians at Blaj in May demanded recognition as a nation and opposed uniting Transylvania with Hungary. Over the next year Romanian and Hungarian villagers killed one another in a bitter civil war.

Lajos Kossuth's government fought on all fronts. In April 1849 it declared Hungary independent of the Habsburgs. Only in July 1849, with defeat close, did the Hungarian parliament at Szeged pass laws granting rights to nationalities and equality to Jews. It was too late. Petőfi fell in battle that month, aged 26, and in August the Hungarian army surrendered. Kossuth fled to the Ottoman Empire.

Slavs in Prague and Lviv

In June 1848 Czech leaders hosted a Slav Congress in Prague, with delegates from across the monarchy and beyond, as an answer to Frankfurt. It called for equality among the peoples of Austria. A street rising in the city gave Windischgrätz the excuse to bombard Prague and close the congress. Further east, in Galicia, Ukrainians, then often called Ruthenians, formed a Supreme Ruthenian Council in Lviv in May 1848. It declared that Ukrainians were a distinct nation, neither Poles nor Russians, and asked for Galicia to be divided between its Polish west and Ukrainian east. Polish leaders had assumed the whole province was theirs.

Poles in Posen

In the Prussian province of Posen, Poles organized a national committee and armed units in the spring. Prussian troops crushed them by May. When the Frankfurt Assembly debated the province in July, the deputy Wilhelm Jordan rejected sympathy for Poland as sentimental and defended what he called healthy national egoism. Many liberals agreed. The rights they demanded for Germans did not stretch to a nation in their way.

Wallachia

The wave even reached the Danube principalities under Ottoman rule. In June 1848 Wallachian liberals issued the Islaz Proclamation, which called for freeing Roma slaves and giving land to peasants, along with equal rights and an elected assembly. A provisional government ruled Bucharest for three months before Ottoman and Russian troops ended it in September. Roma slavery in Wallachia was fully abolished only in 1856.

Worked example: the Croatian question from three sides

Imagine three people in the summer of 1848 arguing about Croatia. Each has a case.

A Hungarian liberal says: Croatia has been linked to the Hungarian crown for over seven centuries. We have just won a constitution, a free press and the end of serf dues for everyone in the kingdom, Croats included. We offer citizens equal rights as individuals. Why should the Croats side with the court that denied all of us freedom?

A Croatian patriot replies: you offer rights to individuals while making Hungarian the language of the state and refusing to treat us as a nation with our own diet and our own tongue. Freedom that requires us to stop being Croats is not freedom for us. If Vienna will protect our nationhood better than Budapest, we will side with Vienna.

An adviser in Vienna listens to both and smiles. Every quarrel between Hungarians and Croats makes the dynasty necessary to someone.

No party here is simply right. The Hungarian points to equal individual rights, the Croat to the right of a people to its own language and institutions, and both claims touch human dignity. The tragedy of 1848 in central Europe was that liberals in each nation demanded freedom for themselves while denying it to their neighbors, and the old powers used that division to defeat them all. Later attempts to reconcile individual rights with the rights of national minorities would grow from the same dilemma.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. How were the Twelve Points printed in Pest on 15 March 1848?
2. Why did many Croats, Serbs and Romanians oppose the Hungarian government?
3. Where did Hungarian forces stop Jelačić's advance in September 1848?
4. What did the Serbian assembly at Sremski Karlovci proclaim in May 1848?
5. What did the Romanian assembly at Blaj oppose in May 1848?
6. What did Hungary's parliament pass at Szeged in July 1849?
7. What did the Supreme Ruthenian Council in Lviv declare in 1848?
8. What did Wilhelm Jordan defend in the Posen debate?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia