Skip to main content

From philosophy to the laboratory

For decades phenomenology was mostly a European academic tradition. Since the 1970s it has moved into fields that might seem far from it. The philosopher Hubert Dreyfus drew on Heidegger and Merleau-Ponty to argue that early artificial intelligence, which tried to capture intelligence in explicit rules, missed the skilled, bodily coping that fills ordinary life.

Embodied and enactive minds

In The Embodied Mind (1991), the biologist Francisco Varela, the philosopher Evan Thompson and the psychologist Eleanor Rosch brought phenomenology, cognitive science and Buddhist meditation practice into conversation. They proposed that cognition is not mainly the building of inner pictures of a ready-made world. It is enaction, the bringing forth of a world through a living body's activity. A frog, a bee and a person live in different worlds of significance because they have different bodies and ways of acting. This view grew into a family of approaches, often called 4E cognition: embodied, embedded, enactive and extended.

A related idea came from the psychologist James J. Gibson, who developed the notion of affordances in The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception (1979). Affordances are possibilities for action that the environment offers an animal: a chair affords sitting to an adult, a step affords climbing, a handle affords pulling. We often perceive what we can do with things as directly as their shapes.

Varela also proposed, in 1996, a program he called neurophenomenology, pairing trained first-person reports with brain measurements so that each could guide the interpretation of the other. Skeptics caution that some popular findings in embodied cognition, especially studies claiming that small bodily cues sway judgment, have failed to replicate. The broader claim that thinking is shaped by having a body is on firmer ground.

The phenomenology of illness

Medicine has proved especially fertile ground. In The Absent Body (1990) the philosopher and physician Drew Leder noted a paradox: the body that shapes every experience is mostly unnoticed. The healthy body recedes from awareness, and it "dys-appears" in pain or illness, surfacing as a problem. A knee is invisible until it aches; then it is all one can think about. The point echoes Heidegger's hammer.

The philosopher S. Kay Toombs, who lived with multiple sclerosis, argued in The Meaning of Illness (1992) that physician and patient live the same illness in different ways. The doctor meets the disease as a case of a category, visible in scans and test results. The patient lives it as lost abilities, a changed relation to stairs and distances, altered time and a shaken sense of self. Neither view is false, but the gap between them can make patients feel unheard.

The philosopher Havi Carel, who has a rare lung disease, went further. Illness, she argued, changes the patient's whole world, not just one part of the body: the places one can go, the future one can plan, the people one can keep up with. She proposed a phenomenological toolkit to help patients reflect on and describe these changes, and she has written about how patients' own accounts are too often discounted.

Design that disappears

Phenomenology has also shaped the design of tools. In Understanding Computers and Cognition (1986), Terry Winograd and Fernando Flores used Heidegger's idea of breakdown to argue that design should anticipate where tools fail, since a good tool stays ready-to-hand and a bad one keeps forcing itself into view. Paul Dourish's Where the Action Is (2001) used phenomenology to argue for embodied interaction, rooted in how people actually handle things. Donald Norman's widely read design book of 1988 borrowed Gibson's affordances, giving designers a word for whether a door shows you to push or to pull.

Fair criticisms

Phenomenology has limits. Psychologists have shown that people often misreport the causes of their own behavior, so first-person description needs checking. And descriptions offered as universal can reflect the describer's own situation, as Young showed for Merleau-Ponty. Defenders answer that phenomenology is a trained, shared practice, tested against other people's experience, and that its job is to describe meaning, which no brain scan reads off by itself.

Worked example: a clinic check-in screen

A hospital replaces its reception desk with a touchscreen kiosk. For most visitors it works: the screen is ready-to-hand and they barely notice it. For a patient with a hand tremor, small buttons demand fine control their body schema cannot provide. The kiosk breaks down, becomes a stubborn object, and the illness, which might otherwise have receded for an hour, dys-appears in public.

A team guided by these ideas would test the kiosk with patients who have tremors, poor sight or chronic pain, attending to what each can do. It would keep a staffed desk, because a screen offers no face to answer to. And it would treat patients' descriptions as evidence about the design, not complaints.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Varela, Thompson and Rosch mean by calling cognition enaction?
2. What are affordances, in Gibson's sense?
3. What did Varela's neurophenomenology propose?
4. According to Drew Leder, what happens to the healthy body?
5. What did S. Kay Toombs argue about illness?
6. How did Havi Carel describe the effect of illness?
7. How did Winograd and Flores use Heidegger's idea of breakdown?
8. Which criticism of phenomenology does this level present?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia