Few conflicts are argued about so fiercely. A fair account starts by understanding why each people believes the land is rightfully its home, and why each remembers the same events so differently.
Two cases, stated at their strongest
The Zionist case rests on history and necessity. Jews have prayed toward Jerusalem for two thousand years and kept a continuous presence in the land. Across Europe and the Middle East they suffered expulsions, massacres and legal exclusion, and Zionists concluded that only a state of their own could keep them safe. The Holocaust seemed to prove that conclusion in the most terrible way. Zionists add that they bought land, built farms and towns, accepted compromise when it was offered, and were attacked when they did.
The Palestinian case rests on presence and consent. Arabs, Muslim and Christian, had lived on the land for many centuries and made up the large majority of its people when Britain arrived. They were never asked whether a national home for another people should be built in their country, and that plan was carried out under the protection of a foreign empire. In their view, the result was the loss of their homeland, the exile of most of their people and a long occupation, all for the crimes of Europeans against Jews in which Palestinians had no part.
The mandate years
Under British rule the Jewish population grew from about 60,000 at the end of the First World War to roughly 600,000 by 1947, about a third of the total, through immigration that surged as persecution in Europe worsened. Arab opposition grew with it. A general strike in 1936 became a revolt that lasted until 1939 and was crushed by British forces. In 1937 the Peel Commission recommended partitioning Palestine into Jewish and Arab states, the first official proposal to divide the land. In 1939, seeking Arab support as war with Germany approached, Britain issued a White Paper that limited Jewish immigration to 75,000 over five years, with later entry subject to Arab consent. Zionists saw it as a betrayal at the very moment Europe's Jews most needed refuge.
Partition and war
Britain handed the problem to the United Nations. On November 29, 1947, the General Assembly voted to partition Palestine into Jewish and Arab states, with Jerusalem under international rule. The Jewish Agency accepted the plan, while Arab leaders and Arab states rejected it, arguing that the majority's land was being divided without its consent and that the Jewish state was allotted over half the territory. Fighting began at once. Atrocities came from both sides: the killing of over a hundred villagers at Deir Yassin by Jewish militias in April 1948, and days later an Arab ambush of a medical convoy to Jerusalem that killed about seventy-eight doctors, nurses and others. On May 14, 1948, David Ben-Gurion declared the State of Israel, and the armies of Egypt, Transjordan, Syria, Iraq and Lebanon entered the war. When armistices were signed in 1949, Israel held about 78 percent of the former mandate. Transjordan held the West Bank and East Jerusalem, and in 1950 Jordan annexed the West Bank; Egypt administered Gaza.
About 700,000 Palestinian Arabs fled or were driven from their homes. Palestinians call this the Nakba, the catastrophe; Israelis remember the war as their war of independence. Why the refugees left is still debated. Palestinian historians such as Walid Khalidi argued that a military plan led to deliberate expulsion. The Israeli historian Benny Morris concluded that there were expulsions in some places and flight from fighting and fear in others, without one master plan, though he also documented massacres. In December 1948 the General Assembly's Resolution 194 stated that refugees wishing to return home and live at peace with their neighbors should be permitted to do so. Israel refused a general return, arguing that it would end the Jewish state. Over the following decades several hundred thousand Jews also left or were pushed out of Arab countries, most settling in Israel, a displacement Israelis point to when the refugee question is raised.
The Six-Day War
In May 1967 Nasser expelled UN peacekeepers from Sinai and closed the Straits of Tiran to Israeli shipping. On June 5 Israel struck first, destroying most of Egypt's air force on the ground. In six days Israel captured Sinai, Gaza, the West Bank, East Jerusalem and the Golan Heights. Israelis saw a war of survival against neighbors who had threatened their destruction; Arabs called it the Naksa, the setback, and some 300,000 more Palestinians were displaced. In September an Arab summit at Khartoum resolved on no peace with Israel, no recognition and no negotiations.
Worked example: Resolution 242
In November 1967 the UN Security Council passed Resolution 242. It called for Israeli withdrawal from territories occupied in the recent conflict and for every state in the area to be able to live in peace within secure and recognized borders. This became the formula known as land for peace.
The wording was deliberately ambiguous. The English text spoke of withdrawal from territories, without the word "the," while the French text used the equivalent of "the territories." Israel and its supporters argued that this meant withdrawal from some, not necessarily all, of the land, with final borders to be negotiated. Arab states read it as requiring withdrawal from all of it. Apply the level's ideas: each side could accept the resolution because each read it through its own claim. Ambiguity made agreement on paper possible, and it left the hard questions for later.
