Skip to main content

After 1920 the generals from Sonora who had won the civil war set about turning a shattered country into a working state. Over fourteen years they built schools and roads, made peace with Washington, fought a religious war and invented a party that would rule for most of the century.

Obregón's peace

Álvaro Obregón was elected president in 1920. He governed by bargaining: generals who accepted the new order received posts, contracts and land, and those who rebelled were crushed. Villa accepted a hacienda at Canutillo in Durango in exchange for retiring, and lived there until he was ambushed and shot in the town of Parral in July 1923.

Vasconcelos and the schools

The most celebrated achievement of these years was in education. José Vasconcelos, a philosopher and lawyer, became the first head of the new Ministry of Public Education, created in 1921. He built hundreds of rural schools, sent traveling cultural missions to train village teachers, and printed cheap editions of classic books for a largely illiterate public. Rural teachers often became agents of the revolution itself, helping villages petition for land and organize against local bosses, which sometimes cost them their lives.

Vasconcelos also commissioned painters to cover the walls of public buildings with murals. Artists such as Diego Rivera, José Clemente Orozco and David Alfaro Siqueiros painted the indigenous past, the conquest and the revolution itself, in places where people who had never entered a museum could see them. The murals helped create a new national story in which Mexico's indigenous and mestizo people, not its European elite, were the heart of the nation. Critics then and since have noted that this celebration of a mixed national identity could also press indigenous communities to give up their own languages and ways of life.

Peace with Washington

The United States had refused to recognize Obregón, largely because American oil and land companies feared Article 27. In the Bucareli Agreements of 1923, Mexico agreed not to apply Article 27 retroactively to oil lands already being worked before 1917. In return Washington recognized Obregón's government and soon sold it weapons, which helped him crush a rebellion led by his former ally Adolfo de la Huerta.

Calles and the Church

Plutarco Elías Calles, another Sonoran general and a former schoolteacher, succeeded Obregón in 1924. He founded the Bank of Mexico in 1925 and allied closely with organized labor. He was also a fierce anticlerical. In 1926 he issued a law, known as the Calles Law, that set penalties for violations of the constitution's religious articles, including wearing clerical dress in public. In protest, the bishops suspended all public worship from the end of July 1926. For the first time in four centuries, Mexican churches held no public Masses.

Within months armed revolt spread across the west central states, above all Jalisco, Michoacán and Guanajuato. The rebels were called Cristeros, after their cry "Long live Christ the King". Many were smallholders and sharecroppers who had gained little from land reform or distrusted it. Both sides committed atrocities: the army hanged rebels from telegraph poles and moved villagers into camps, while some Cristeros killed rural teachers and attacked a passenger train. Estimates suggest that around ninety thousand combatants died, along with many civilians. In 1929 a settlement brokered with help from the American ambassador, Dwight Morrow, allowed worship to resume; the laws stayed on the books but were enforced less harshly.

The death of Obregón and a new party

The principle of no re-election did not stop Obregón. Congress amended the constitution to allow a non-consecutive second term, and he won the election of July 1928. Two weeks later, at a banquet in a restaurant outside Mexico City, he was shot dead by José de León Toral, a young Catholic militant posing as a sketch artist.

In his last address to Congress in September 1928, Calles declared that Mexico must pass from a country of strongmen to a nation of institutions. Six months later, in March 1929, he founded the National Revolutionary Party, the PNR, which brought the revolution's quarreling generals and regional bosses into one organization where succession could be negotiated rather than fought over. Calles, called the Jefe Máximo, or highest chief, then dominated three short presidencies from behind the scenes, a period known as the Maximato.

Worked example: the Cristero War as a clash of rights

The two sides told opposite stories about the Cristero War. For the government, the Church had long sided with landlords and dictators, opposed the revolution's reforms and kept the poor obedient; a secular state with secular schools was a condition of freedom. For the Cristeros, the state was banning their priests, closing their churches and taking their children's education out of their hands; they were defending liberty of conscience against a government that tolerated no rival loyalty.

A fair judgment separates the questions. A state may rightly insist that public schools be secular and that churches obey the law. But forbidding clergy to speak on public questions, limiting how many priests a state may have and punishing the wearing of a cassock go beyond neutrality toward the suppression of a faith. Equally, the cause of religious freedom did not justify killing schoolteachers. Both sides claimed to defend human dignity; both violated it. Taking freedom of conscience seriously means protecting it even for people whose beliefs and loyalties one distrusts.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. How did Pancho Villa die in July 1923?
2. What post did José Vasconcelos hold from 1921?
3. What did Vasconcelos commission painters to do?
4. What did Mexico agree to in the Bucareli Agreements of 1923?
5. What did the bishops do in protest in July 1926?
6. Where did the Cristeros get their name?
7. Who helped broker the 1929 settlement that ended the Cristero War?
8. What did Calles found in March 1929?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia