Skip to main content

Meiji leaders believed that in a world of empires a nation either expanded or was swallowed. Their critics, then and later, asked whether a country that complained of unequal treaties should impose them on its neighbors. Both the fear and the contradiction shaped Japan's path from 1874 to 1912.

First steps abroad

In 1871 sailors from the Ryukyu Islands, a kingdom that paid tribute to both China and Japan, were shipwrecked on Taiwan and dozens were killed by local people. The killing of the Ryukyuan sailors led to a Japanese expedition to Taiwan in 1874, which China ended by paying compensation, implicitly accepting Japan's claim to speak for the islanders. In 1879 Japan annexed the kingdom as Okinawa Prefecture and moved its king to Tokyo. In 1876 Japan forced an unequal treaty on Korea, using methods Perry had used on Japan.

War with China and the Triple Intervention

Rivalry over Korea brought war with Qing China in 1894. Japan's modern army and navy won quickly, and the peace of 1895 gave it Taiwan, the Liaodong Peninsula in southern Manchuria and a huge indemnity. Days later Russia, France and Germany forced Japan to return the Liaodong Peninsula in exchange for extra payment, and Russia soon leased its tip for itself. Japanese anger at the Triple Intervention was intense, and the government answered with a decade of military spending. Taiwan's people resisted Japanese rule for years.

Russia and Korea

In 1902 Japan signed an alliance with Britain that treated it as an equal partner, a sign of how far its standing had risen. In February 1904 Japan attacked Russian ships at Port Arthur. The war cost huge casualties, especially in the long siege of Port Arthur, and by 1905 both sides were exhausted. Theodore Roosevelt mediated the peace, signed at Portsmouth, New Hampshire, in September 1905, and won the Nobel Peace Prize for it. Japan gained the Liaodong lease, a railway in southern Manchuria, the southern half of Sakhalin and a free hand in Korea, but no indemnity. On the day of signing, crowds in Tokyo's Hibiya Park rioted because the treaty brought no indemnity, burning police boxes and churches; seventeen people died and martial law followed. Japan made Korea a protectorate in 1905 with Ito Hirobumi as its first resident-general. After a Korean nationalist killed Ito at Harbin in 1909, Japan annexed Korea in 1910.

Ending the unequal treaties

Treaty revision was the great diplomatic goal of the era. A case in 1886 showed why. When the British steamer Normanton sank off the coast of Wakayama, the British crew took to the boats and every Japanese passenger drowned. A British consular court at first acquitted the captain; after an outcry he was retried and given three months in prison. Revision efforts stalled repeatedly, and in 1889 a nationalist threw a bomb at the foreign minister Okuma Shigenobu, who lost a leg, because his draft would have allowed foreign judges in Japanese courts. Britain finally agreed in 1894, and consular jurisdiction ended in 1899. Full control of tariffs followed in 1911.

Voices of dissent

Not everyone cheered. Socialists such as Kotoku Shusui opposed the war with Russia in their own weekly paper. In 1904 the poet Yosano Akiko published a poem urging her younger brother, a soldier at Port Arthur, not to die, and critics called it disloyal. In 1911 Hiratsuka Raicho founded the literary magazine Seito, Bluestocking, run by women, which opened with her declaration that woman had once been the sun and was now a pale moon.

The end of Meiji

Emperor Meiji died on 30 July 1912. On the evening of his funeral in September, General Nogi Maresuke, the commander at Port Arthur, and his wife Shizuko took their own lives on the day of the funeral, following their lord in death in an old samurai custom. Many admired the act; others found it a startling throwback. Historians still debate what the era was. Some see a revolution from above that gave Japan schools, industry and a constitution under impossible pressure. Marxist historians saw an absolutist state that left landlords and oligarchs in charge. Others stress a third story: the people who shaped Meiji from below, in petitions, draft constitutions and protests.

Worked example: the High Treason trial

In 1910 police discovered that a small group of anarchists had planned to kill the emperor with a bomb. The government used the plot to strike at the whole left. Twenty-six people were tried in secret on a charge of plotting against the imperial family. In January 1911 twenty-four were sentenced to death; half had their sentences reduced to life, and twelve, including Kotoku Shusui and the journalist Kanno Suga, were hanged within a week. Historians agree that only a handful had any real part in the plot, and that Kotoku's role is doubtful.

Defenders of the government argued that a threat to the emperor was a threat to the state itself. Critics, including the novelist Tokutomi Roka in a lecture to students that year, said the state had killed people for their beliefs. The case closed the Meiji era with a warning. A constitution can promise rights, but when trials are secret and the charge is loyalty, the promise is only as strong as the courage of those who insist on it.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What led to Japan's expedition to Taiwan in 1874?
2. What did the Triple Intervention of 1895 force Japan to do?
3. Who mediated the peace between Japan and Russia in 1905?
4. Why did crowds riot in Hibiya Park in September 1905?
5. What did a British consular court first do in the Normanton case?
6. When did consular jurisdiction over foreigners in Japan end?
7. What did Yosano Akiko's poem of 1904 urge her brother?
8. What did General Nogi and his wife do on the day of the emperor's funeral?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia