Skip to main content

After Ii's death the shogunate tried to rule by compromise. It married the young shogun Iemochi to the emperor's sister and promised the court that foreigners would be expelled at some future date. Neither move restored its authority. Through the 1860s power drained from Edo toward Kyoto, where activist samurai, court nobles and the great southwestern domains competed to speak for the throne.

Expulsion meets reality

Some loyalist samurai took expulsion into their own hands. In September 1862 retainers of the Satsuma regent Shimazu Hisamitsu cut down an English merchant, Charles Richardson, who had ridden into their procession at the village of Namamugi. The Namamugi Incident was the killing of a British merchant by Satsuma retainers. When Satsuma refused to hand over the killers, a British squadron bombarded Kagoshima in 1863, the domain's castle town. Choshu went further. On the date the court had set for expulsion in 1863 its shore guns fired on foreign ships in the Shimonoseki Strait. In 1864 a fleet from Britain, France, the Netherlands and the United States destroyed its batteries. Both domains drew the same lesson: expulsion was impossible for now, and Japan needed Western arms to survive.

New armies

Choshu's defeats opened the way for new men. In 1863 the samurai Takasugi Shinsaku formed militia units, the best known called the Kiheitai, and these units enlisted commoners alongside samurai, trained them with rifles and promoted by ability. In a short civil war in 1865 such forces put a radical faction in control of Choshu. The shogunate sent armies to punish the domain, and it modernized its own troops with help from abroad. France advised the shogunate on military reform, while British diplomats grew friendly with Satsuma and Choshu.

The alliance

Satsuma and Choshu had been bitter rivals, and in 1864 their troops had fought each other in Kyoto. In early 1866 they agreed to cooperate, a pact that Sakamoto Ryoma, a samurai from Tosa, helped broker, though historians debate how central his part was. Satsuma quietly bought rifles for Choshu. When the shogunate's second expedition against Choshu went into the field that summer, it was beaten, and the shogun Iemochi died in camp. His successor, Tokugawa Yoshinobu, was able and reform minded, but time was short. He reorganized the shogunate's councils on French advice, began building a modern army and courted foreign envoys at Osaka. To his enemies in Satsuma and Choshu, these reforms were a reason to move quickly, since a revived shogunate backed by France might yet outlast them.

Restoration

Emperor Komei died in early 1867, leaving the throne to his fourteen-year-old son, Mutsuhito, later known as Emperor Meiji. That autumn, in towns along the Tokaido and beyond, crowds danced through the streets chanting "ee ja nai ka," "isn't it fine," after reports that protective charms had fallen from the sky. In November Yoshinobu formally returned his governing powers to the court, hoping to lead a new council of lords. Instead, on 3 January 1868, Satsuma and allied troops seized the palace gates and the court proclaimed the restoration of imperial rule, stripping Yoshinobu of his lands and office.

The Boshin War

Fighting began near Kyoto at Toba and Fushimi late in January 1868, and the shogun's larger army was routed. Yoshinobu fled to Edo, then chose to submit. Resistance continued in the northeast. Aizu held out through a month-long siege before surrendering in November 1868, and during the fighting a group of teenage soldiers of its White Tiger unit killed themselves on a hillside, believing their castle had fallen. Aizu's suffering was remembered bitterly in the region for generations. The last holdouts gathered in the far north at Hakodate, where former shogunal naval officers set up a short-lived state. Enomoto Takeaki led this Republic of Ezo until it surrendered in June 1869. Enomoto was jailed, pardoned, and later served the new government as a minister.

Worked example: the surrender of Edo

In the spring of 1868 imperial armies marched on Edo, a city of perhaps a million people. Saigo Takamori of Satsuma commanded the advance. Katsu Kaishu, a shogunal official who had sailed to America in 1860, negotiated for the Tokugawa side. Katsu had let it be known that if the city were attacked it would be burned and its people evacuated by boat, so that the attackers would win only ashes. After two days of talks in April, Saigo agreed to call off the assault in return for the shogun's retirement and the handover of the castle, and Edo Castle was surrendered without a battle in May.

Why did both men choose restraint? Each had reasons of interest: Saigo wanted a quick victory and foreign diplomats were urging moderation, while Katsu wanted to save his master's life and household. But the result mattered far beyond them. The largest city in the country passed to a new government with little bloodshed. Revolutions are often judged by their ideals, yet the decisions that spare ordinary people from the fighting can count for as much as any manifesto.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What was the Namamugi Incident of 1862?
2. What happened to Kagoshima in 1863?
3. What was unusual about Takasugi Shinsaku's Kiheitai?
4. Who helped broker the alliance between Satsuma and Choshu in 1866?
5. Which foreign power advised the shogunate on military reform?
6. What did crowds do in the ee ja nai ka outbreaks of 1867?
7. Who led the short-lived Republic of Ezo at Hakodate?
8. How did Edo Castle change hands in 1868?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia