Charles of Habsburg was born in Ghent in 1500 and grew up speaking French. By the age of nineteen he had inherited the Netherlands from his father, Spain and its American conquests from his mother's family, and the Austrian lands from his grandfather Maximilian. No European ruler since Charlemagne had held so much. The question his reign posed was whether any one person could govern it.
The election of 1519
The imperial crown still had to be won. When Maximilian died in 1519, King Francis I of France and King Henry VIII of England also sought the title. The electors expected gifts, and the contest became an auction. Charles won the imperial election of 1519 with huge loans from the Fugger bankers of Augsburg and other lenders. The debt tied the Habsburg crown to German and Genoese finance for generations, and later Spanish kings declared bankruptcy several times.
Charles chose as his personal motto "Plus Ultra", meaning "further beyond". It reversed an old warning said to be written on the Pillars of Hercules at the mouth of the Mediterranean, and it suited a monarchy whose lands reached across the Atlantic. Spain still carries the words on its coat of arms. The phrase captured a new kind of ambition: a dynasty that had begun with a castle in the Alps now thought of itself as ruling a world monarchy, with Christian unity under its leadership as its stated aim.
An empire that never sat still
Charles spent his reign on the move, by one count making dozens of journeys between his realms. France, surrounded by Habsburg lands, fought him repeatedly. At the Battle of Pavia in 1525, imperial troops captured King Francis I, who was held in Madrid until he signed a treaty he later disowned. In 1527 unpaid imperial soldiers sacked Rome itself, a disaster Charles had not ordered but could not escape. Three years later Pope Clement VII crowned him at Bologna. Charles V was the last emperor crowned by a pope; his successors were simply elected and crowned in Germany.
The religious split in Germany, war with the Ottomans in the Mediterranean and Hungary, and constant war with France wore him down. In a series of ceremonies in 1555 and 1556 he gave up his crowns, an almost unheard of step for a ruler of his standing. Charles abdicated and retired to the monastery of Yuste in Spain, where he died in 1558.
Two branches of one family
Charles divided his inheritance. His son Philip II received Spain and its empire, while his brother Ferdinand kept Austria and the imperial title. Philip also took the Netherlands, Milan, Naples and Sicily. From then on there were two Habsburg lines, the Spanish and the Austrian. They usually cooperated, sent each other soldiers and money, and married each other's children again and again to keep the inheritances in the family.
The Spanish line governed a global empire under Philip II, Philip III and Philip IV, but it drew on narrower and narrower family ties. Philip IV married his own niece, Mariana of Austria. Their son, Charles II, came to the throne as a sickly child in 1665. He had great difficulty eating and speaking, and he was often ill. Charles II of Spain died childless in 1700, and with him the Spanish line ended.
His will left everything to Philip of Anjou, a grandson of Louis XIV of France. The Austrian Habsburgs, backed by Britain and the Dutch, refused to accept a Bourbon in Madrid. The War of the Spanish Succession lasted from 1701 to 1714. Philip kept Spain and its American empire, but Austria gained the Spanish Netherlands, Milan and Naples, which pulled the center of Habsburg power still further into Central Europe and Italy.
Worked example: measuring a dynasty's inbreeding
Portraits of Habsburg rulers often show a long lower jaw and a heavy lower lip, a look so familiar that people call it the "Habsburg jaw". Was it the result of generations of marriage between close relatives? Two scientific studies tried to answer that question.
In 2009 a team of Spanish geneticists led by Gonzalo Álvarez traced the family trees of the Spanish kings over sixteen generations. They calculated an inbreeding coefficient, which estimates the probability that a person inherited two identical copies of a gene from a shared ancestor. For a child of unrelated parents it is close to zero; for a child of first cousins it is about 0.06. For Charles II they estimated about 0.25, roughly what one would expect from a union of brother and sister. The team argued that inbreeding probably contributed to his poor health and to high infant death rates in the family.
A second study, published in 2019, asked specialists in facial surgery to score features in dozens of portraits, and found that the degree of jaw deformity rose with the degree of inbreeding. Both studies have limits. Portrait painters flattered and exaggerated, records of early deaths are incomplete, and an inbreeding estimate does not prove what caused any particular illness. Still, the case shows how a political strategy, keeping crowns inside one family, could have biological costs, and how historians and scientists can test a popular story instead of simply repeating it.
