Skip to main content

For most of the nineteenth century Spaniards called Cuba the "ever faithful isle." While Spain lost Mexico, Peru and nearly all the rest of its American empire in the 1810s and 1820s, Cuba stayed loyal. Cuba's planters were growing rich, and they were afraid.

The sugar boom

The revolution in nearby Saint-Domingue, which became independent Haiti in 1804, destroyed what had been the world's richest sugar colony. Cuban planters moved into the gap. With steam mills, and with a railway that opened in 1837, eleven years before Spain's own first line, Cuba became one of the world's leading sugar producers, at times the largest. The cane was cut by enslaved Africans. Spain signed treaties with Britain in 1817 and 1835 to end the slave trade, yet smugglers carried hundreds of thousands of captives to the island in the following decades while officials looked away. When that supply tightened, planters also brought in about 125,000 Chinese indentured laborers between 1847 and 1874, bound by contracts that in practice often differed little from slavery.

Why Cuba stayed loyal

Fear of a second Haiti held the colony together. White Creole planters, born in Cuba, resented Spanish taxes, trade rules and the grip of Spanish born officials on high office. But they feared a slave rising like Haiti's even more, and Spanish troops were their insurance. Some planters looked instead to annexation by the United States, where slavery was still protected. In 1848 President James Polk offered Spain one hundred million dollars for the island. Spain refused.

The cry of 1868

The break came in the poorer east, where estates were smaller and planters had fewer slaves to lose. On 10 October 1868 Carlos Manuel de Céspedes, a lawyer and planter, freed his slaves at his estate La Demajagua and called for independence, inviting the freed men to fight beside him. The rising is remembered as the Grito de Yara, the cry of Yara, and it began the Ten Years' War.

The rebels, called mambises, were a mix of planters, small farmers, free people of color and former slaves. In April 1869 an assembly at Guáimaro wrote a constitution that declared all inhabitants free and named Céspedes president. In practice the leaders moved cautiously on slavery, hoping not to frighten the western planters whose support they wanted. That caution was one of several divisions. Civilian legislators clashed with generals, easterners distrusted westerners, and the Dominican born general Máximo Gómez argued for carrying the war into the rich western sugar districts, mostly in vain. The rebel assembly deposed Céspedes in 1873, and Spanish troops killed him in 1874.

Spain answered with a large army and with volunteer militias of loyalist Spaniards in Havana. Most of the fighting consisted of raids, burned estates and executed prisoners. Deaths from combat and disease ran to many tens of thousands, though estimates vary widely.

Zanjón and Baraguá

Exhausted, most rebel leaders accepted the Pact of Zanjón in February 1878. It offered amnesty and limited reforms, but not independence, and it freed only those slaves and Chinese laborers who had fought in the rebel ranks. One commander refused. Antonio Maceo, a mixed race general from Oriente, met the Spanish commander at Baraguá in March 1878, rejected the peace and demanded independence and an end to slavery. The Protest of Baraguá became a lasting symbol of uncompromising patriotism, though Maceo soon had to leave the island. A further rising, the Little War of 1879 to 1880, failed quickly.

Slavery still ended, in stages. The Moret Law of 1870 had freed children born to enslaved mothers and people over sixty. A law of 1880 turned the remaining slaves into patrocinados, apprentices still bound to their masters for a set number of years. Spain abolished slavery in Cuba entirely in 1886, two years ahead of schedule. The war had made the old system hard to sustain, since so many enslaved people had fled, fought or bargained for their freedom.

Worked example: reading a gesture

Why did Céspedes free his slaves on the first day of the war? A patriotic reading says he acted from principle: a free Cuba could not be built on bondage. A strategic reading says he needed soldiers and could hardly ask men to fight for a freedom they would not share. A cautious reading notes that although the Guáimaro constitution freed all inhabitants, rebel rules soon required freed people to keep working under supervision, which suggests the leaders wanted to manage abolition rather than unleash it.

The evidence supports each reading in part. Céspedes wrote of liberty in broad terms, and he also faced Spanish propaganda warning white Cubans that the rebels meant a race war like Haiti's. Freeing his own slaves, while moving slowly on everyone else's, answered both needs at once. The lesson is that a single act can carry conviction and calculation together, and that historians usually learn more by asking how motives combined than by picking one. The episode also shows a tension that would run through Cuban history: independence was presented as a cause above race, while the question of who would hold land and power afterward stayed unsettled.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Why did many wealthy Cuban planters stay loyal to Spain in the early 1800s?
2. What did Carlos Manuel de Céspedes do on 10 October 1868?
3. Who argued for carrying the Ten Years' War into the western sugar districts?
4. What did the Pact of Zanjón (1878) offer the rebels?
5. What did Antonio Maceo do at Baraguá in March 1878?
6. When did Spain abolish slavery in Cuba entirely?
7. Whom did Cuban planters bring in as indentured laborers from 1847 to 1874?
8. What did Spain's 1880 law make of the remaining slaves?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia