Skip to main content

In August 1812, former president Thomas Jefferson predicted that taking Canada as far as Quebec would be "a mere matter of marching." The United States had just declared war on Britain, and Upper Canada, with only about seventy-five thousand settlers, many of them recent arrivals from the United States, looked easy to seize. Three years later the border was exactly where it had been.

The War of 1812

The Americans went to war over British seizures of sailors and ships at sea and British support for Indigenous resistance in the Ohio country. For Britain the war was a sideshow to the struggle against Napoleon, and Upper Canada's defense rested on a small force of regulars, local militia and Indigenous allies. The most important ally was the Shawnee leader Tecumseh, who had built a confederacy of nations to stop American expansion. Together with the British general Isaac Brock, he captured Detroit in August 1812. Brock was killed at the Battle of Queenston Heights in October 1812, though his side won the battle.

The war swung back and forth. In April 1813 American troops captured York, the capital of Upper Canada, and burned its parliament buildings; in 1814 British forces burned public buildings in Washington. Tecumseh died at the Battle of the Thames in October 1813, and with him went the best hope for an Indigenous homeland in the west. Laura Secord's walk to warn the British in 1813 became a national legend, though the victory at Beaver Dams that followed was won mainly by Mohawk and other Indigenous warriors.

The peace was a draw. The Treaty of Ghent of 1814 restored the borders as they had been before the war. For British North Americans, the war became a founding story of resistance to American conquest. For their allies it was a betrayal. Indigenous nations, who had fought to protect their lands, gained nothing from the peace, and British promises of a protected territory were dropped.

Rule by the few

After the war, both Canadas had elected assemblies, but the real power lay with governors sent from Britain and the councils they appointed. In Upper Canada a tight circle of officials, judges and Anglican clergy, nicknamed the Family Compact, dominated those councils. In Lower Canada a similar group, mostly English-speaking merchants and officials, was called the Château Clique. The French-speaking majority controlled the assembly but could not control the government.

Reformers demanded change. In Lower Canada, Louis-Joseph Papineau and his Patriotes listed their grievances in the Ninety-Two Resolutions of 1834. London rejected them in 1837 and allowed the governor to spend public money without the assembly's consent. Armed risings followed. In November 1837 the Patriotes won a skirmish at Saint-Denis but were crushed at Saint-Charles and Saint-Eustache. In December, William Lyon Mackenzie led a smaller, chaotic rising near Toronto that collapsed within days. A second Patriote rising in 1838 also failed. In Lower Canada twelve rebels were hanged and fifty-eight transported to Australia.

Durham's report

Britain sent Lord Durham to investigate. His report of 1839 made two main recommendations. Durham proposed uniting the two Canadas and granting them responsible government. Union, he hoped, would assimilate the French Canadians, whom he described as "a people with no history, and no literature." The first recommendation was adopted at once. The Act of Union created the Province of Canada in 1841, giving each half equal seats although the French-speaking east had more people.

The second took longer. Responsible government means the cabinet must keep the confidence of the elected assembly or resign, so that the governor acts on its advice rather than ruling through favorites. Reformers on both sides of the language divide worked together for it. Robert Baldwin of Canada West and Louis-Hippolyte LaFontaine of Canada East formed an alliance so close that each helped the other win a seat in his own half of the province. Nova Scotia became the first colony to gain responsible government, early in 1848, after a long campaign led by the journalist Joseph Howe. The Province of Canada followed weeks later, under a ministry led by LaFontaine and Baldwin.

The test came in 1849. The new ministry passed the Rebellion Losses Bill, compensating people in Canada East whose property had been damaged during the risings. Tories protested that rebels would be rewarded. Governor General Lord Elgin signed the Rebellion Losses Bill despite his own doubts, and an angry crowd pelted his carriage and burned the parliament building in Montreal.

Worked example: why Elgin signed

Elgin privately disliked parts of the bill and had the legal power to refuse it. Why did he sign? Its authors held a clear majority that voters had just elected. If he vetoed their central measure, he would be ruling as governors had ruled before 1837, against the wishes of the elected house. Signing meant his own judgment no longer decided colonial policy.

The mob that burned the parliament claimed to defend loyalty to the crown, yet the crown's representative stood with the elected majority. The episode settled the principle in practice. Self-government in Canada would grow not through revolution but through conventions, unwritten rules that officials agree to follow. That pattern, gradual and negotiated, would mark Canada's road to independence for the next century.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Where was Isaac Brock killed in 1812?
2. What did the Treaty of Ghent of 1814 do to borders?
3. What did Indigenous allies gain from the peace of 1814?
4. What penalty did Lower Canada's rebels face?
5. What did Lord Durham recommend in 1839?
6. What does responsible government mean?
7. Which colony first won responsible government?
8. What did Lord Elgin do with the Rebellion Losses Bill?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia