In the spring of 1808 the Spanish monarchy fell apart. Napoleon, whose troops were already in Spain on their way to Portugal, exploited a quarrel in the royal family. After a riot at Aranjuez, Charles IV was forced in March 1808 to abdicate in favor of his son, Ferdinand VII. Within weeks Napoleon held both of them in France and had given the crown to his brother Joseph. For the first time in three centuries, Spain had no legitimate king on Spanish soil. Every official in the Americas faced the same question: in whose name do we govern?
Sovereignty returns to the people
In Spain itself, towns and provinces refused to accept Joseph and set up their own governing committees, called juntas. They justified this with an old idea in Spanish political thought: when the king is absent, sovereignty reverts to the people, or to the communities that make up the kingdom. In September 1808 the provincial juntas formed a Supreme Central Junta to govern in Ferdinand's name. In January 1809 it declared that the American lands were not colonies but integral parts of the monarchy, and it invited them to send deputies. But the numbers told another story: the Americas were given far fewer seats than Spain, roughly nine against three dozen, though they had more people. Creoles noticed.
Americans asked an obvious question. If the towns of Spain could form juntas, why not the towns of America? The empire, many argued, was a set of kingdoms bound to the king, not to Spain. With the king gone, each could govern itself.
The first juntas
The first attempts came in 1809 and were crushed. In Upper Peru, now Bolivia, juntas formed in Chuquisaca in May and in La Paz in July. The La Paz leaders were executed by troops sent from Peru. In Quito a junta took power on 10 August 1809, and it too was put down. In August 1810 royal soldiers killed dozens of its imprisoned members in their cells.
Then, in early 1810, news arrived that French armies had overrun nearly all of Spain. The Central Junta dissolved itself and handed power to a small Regency Council on the island of León, beside Cádiz. To many Americans this body looked like a handful of men under siege with no claim on their obedience. A wave of juntas followed. Caracas acted on 19 April 1810. In Buenos Aires an open town meeting voted out the viceroy, and on 25 May 1810 a junta replaced him; Argentines still call this the May Revolution. Bogotá followed on 20 July, after a quarrel over a borrowed flower vase in a Spanish merchant's shop turned into a riot. Santiago de Chile formed a junta on 18 September.
The mask of Ferdinand
Almost all of these juntas swore loyalty to Ferdinand VII and claimed to govern on his behalf until he returned. Were they sincere? Some leaders already wanted independence and were using the king's name as cover, a tactic later called "the mask of Ferdinand". Others truly saw themselves as loyal subjects defending the monarchy against the French. The honest answer is that motives varied by person and changed over time. What is clear is that the juntas began to act like governments: they opened ports, appointed officials and raised troops.
The Cortes of Cádiz
Meanwhile the Regency summoned a parliament, the Cortes, which opened in September 1810 with American deputies, many of them substitutes chosen from Americans living in Spain. The Cortes decreed press freedom, abolished Indian tribute and, in March 1812, issued a constitution for the whole Spanish world. American deputies pushed for representation based on total population. The majority refused a full count: the constitution denied citizenship to people of African descent unless the Cortes granted it for merit, which cut the number of American seats. The constitution was applied in the loyal parts of the Americas, where elections were held for town councils and provincial bodies. When Ferdinand returned to Spain in 1814, he abolished the constitution outright and ruled as an absolute king.
Worked example: the balcony in Caracas
On 19 April 1810, Holy Thursday, the town council of Caracas met with the captain general, Vicente Emparan, a Spaniard appointed by the old government. As news from Spain spread, a crowd gathered in the main square. Emparan stepped onto a balcony and asked the people whether they wanted him to keep governing. Behind him, a priest named José Cortés de Madariaga signaled to the crowd to say no. The crowd shouted that they did not. Emparan replied that he did not want command either, and the council took power as a junta.
The scene shows how the crisis worked. No one fired a shot. The council used a legal claim that the community could govern itself, and the crowd supplied public consent. Yet the people in the square were mostly from the city's better classes, while the enslaved and the poor were not consulted. Even a peaceful revolution raised the question of who "the people" were, and within two years that question would tear Venezuela apart.
