Skip to main content

Bronze or brass?

The objects known around the world as the Benin Bronzes include heads, plaques, figures, bells, altar pieces and ornaments, along with many works in ivory, wood and coral. The name is a little misleading. Most of the Benin Bronzes are made of brass, an alloy of copper and zinc, rather than bronze, which is copper and tin. Museums and scholars keep the familiar name, but the difference matters for understanding where the metal came from.

The lost-wax method

Benin casters used the lost-wax method, known in many parts of the world. A caster built a core of clay, covered it with a layer of wax shaped into the final form, and added fine detail in the wax. The model was coated in more clay to make a mold, with channels left open. When the mold was heated, the wax melted and ran out, leaving a hollow space. Molten brass was poured in to fill it. When the metal cooled, the caster broke the mold away. Because each mold is broken to free the casting, every lost-wax work is unique, and a mistake meant starting again.

Where the metal came from

West Africa had copper deposits, but Benin's court used large quantities of imported brass. Much of it arrived as manillas, horseshoe-shaped bracelets that European traders brought by the shipload and that served as money along the coast. A chemical study published in 2023 compared the metal in manillas found in shipwrecks with brass from Benin objects, and concluded that many manillas used in Benin brass were made in the German Rhineland. The finding tied the court's art to the Atlantic trade in a very direct way, since manillas were among the goods Europeans paid for ivory, pepper and captives.

Heads, tusks and plaques

Some of the most famous works were made for royal altars. When an oba died, his successor set up an altar for him, and brass heads stood on altars for past obas, often holding carved tusks: a hole in the top of the head held an elephant tusk carved with scenes of royal history. The heads were not portraits in the modern sense. They showed the ideal of the kingship, calm and powerful, wearing high coral collars. The scholar William Fagg proposed that heads grew larger and heavier over time, as more brass reached Benin, and used that idea to date them. Later researchers have questioned his scheme, and the dating of many heads remains uncertain.

The rectangular plaques are another famous group. They show obas, chiefs, warriors, musicians, animals and Portuguese visitors, cast in high relief, and were nailed to the wooden pillars of the palace. Most specialists date most plaques to roughly 1550 to 1650, though no plaque carries a date. By the late nineteenth century they were no longer on display, and many were found in storage when the palace was seized in 1897.

Animals carry meanings throughout this art. Leopards stand for the oba's power over the wild and his right to take life. The mudfish, at home in water and on land, symbolized the oba's power in two worlds, joining his rule on earth with Olokun's realm of the sea. Some images show the oba with legs that end in mudfish, a sign of his more than human nature.

The queen mother's mask

Among Benin's ivories, a small group of pendant masks has become world famous. They are usually linked to Idia, mother of Oba Esigie, who held the rank of queen mother in the early sixteenth century and was remembered for her help in war. An oba wore an ivory pendant mask at his hip during rites, honoring his queen mother and drawing on her protective power. The best known masks have a crown of tiny Portuguese heads.

One of these masks became a symbol of modern Nigeria. An ivory mask of Queen Mother Idia became the emblem of FESTAC 77, the World Black and African Festival of Arts and Culture held in Lagos in 1977. The British Museum declined Nigeria's request to borrow the original for the festival, saying the ivory was too fragile to travel, and Nigeria displayed a copy instead.

Worked example: reading the Idia mask

Picture the mask in a glass case: an oval face carved in ivory, about a hand and a half tall, with inlaid iron in the eyes and forehead, a choker of beads at the neck and a band of small bearded heads across the top. How do we read it?

Start with function. This was not made to hang on a wall. It was worn on the body of the oba, at ceremonies where his queen mother's spiritual protection mattered. The face is calm and idealized, as royal images in Benin usually were.

Next, look at the small heads. They show Portuguese men with long hair and beards. Ivory is white, the color of Olokun and of purity, and the Portuguese came by sea, from Olokun's realm, bringing wealth. Placing them in the crown of the queen mother links her son's reign to that wealth and to the alliance that helped him win his war.

Finally, consider its later life. Seized in 1897, it entered a museum where it was studied as a masterpiece of world art. In 1977 it became the face of a festival that celebrated African achievement, while the original stayed in London. One object now carries three meanings: a royal ornament, a work of art, and a symbol of what was taken.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What are most of the Benin Bronzes actually made of?
2. Why is every lost-wax casting unique?
3. Where did a 2023 study conclude many manillas used in Benin brass were made?
4. What stood on the altars of past obas?
5. To roughly which period do specialists date most Benin plaques?
6. What did the mudfish symbolize in Benin art?
7. Where did an oba wear an ivory pendant mask?
8. What became the emblem of FESTAC 77?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia