Skip to main content

The land and the people

In the rain forest west of the lower Niger River, in what is now Edo State in southern Nigeria, grew one of the longest lasting kingdoms in West Africa. Its people are the Edo, who speak a language of the same name, and the Edo call both their capital and their kingdom Edo. The name Benin, used by outsiders for more than five centuries, probably came into Portuguese from a form of the name used by neighbors, though its exact origin is still discussed. The kingdom is not the same as the modern Republic of Benin to the west, a former French colony that took the name in 1975.

The forest shaped how people lived. Rain falls for most of the year, cleared soil loses its fertility quickly, and the tsetse fly carries a disease that kills horses and most cattle. The tsetse fly made it hard to keep horses in the forest, so Benin never built the cavalry armies of the savanna states to the north. Its soldiers fought on foot, and goods moved on human heads and in canoes along the creeks.

Farmers cleared plots by hand and burned the brush, then let the land rest for years before planting again. Yams were the staple crop of the Edo farming year, supported by plantains, oil palms and vegetables, and the yam harvest set the rhythm of many rites. Long before there were kings, villages ran their own affairs. Men were grouped by age into grades with different duties: young men did heavy public work, men of middle years served as warriors and organizers, and the eldest men, called the edion, led village affairs and spoke for the ancestors. Kings later learned to rule through this village order rather than sweep it away.

A capital at the center

At the heart of the kingdom stood the capital, Benin City, ringed by a deep ditch and a high bank of earth. Broad roads crossed it, and a royal palace filled a whole district. Around the palace lived wards of craftsmen, each organized as a guild serving the king. The city was the center of politics, religion and art at once: the place where the king performed the rites that kept the kingdom in balance, where chiefs competed for titles and where artists recorded the deeds of rulers.

Four kinds of evidence

Benin wrote no books of its own before the twentieth century, yet historians know a surprising amount about it, because four kinds of evidence overlap. The first is oral tradition. Palace officials, chiefs and priests memorized the order of kings, the origins of titles and the reasons for rites, and taught them to their successors. In the twentieth century Jacob Egharevba wrote down palace traditions in A Short History of Benin, first published in the 1930s and revised many times. His king list, with a date for each reign, is still widely used.

Those dates need care. Before about 1500 no outside writer recorded a Benin reign, so early dates in the king list are estimates built from counts of reigns, assuming a typical length for each. A king placed around 1440 might have ruled decades earlier or later.

The second kind of evidence is the art of the court. Brass heads, brass plaques and carved ivory tusks show rulers, chiefs, soldiers, foreigners and ceremonies, and some were made to commemorate particular events. The third is the writing of European visitors from the 1480s onward: Portuguese, Dutch and English traders, priests and officials. The fourth is archaeology. The archaeologist Graham Connah excavated in Benin City in the 1960s, dating layers of the city's earthworks and buildings and showing that the site was occupied and reshaped over many centuries.

Each kind of evidence has its own slant. Oral traditions were kept by people close to the throne, so they tend to justify the royal house and the titles of those who told them. European writers saw only what their hosts allowed and often judged Benin by home standards. One of the most quoted descriptions comes from the Dutch physician Olfert Dapper, published in Amsterdam in 1668. Dapper never visited Benin and relied on the reports of Dutch traders, combining accounts gathered over many years.

Worked example: reading Dapper

Dapper describes a large city with long, straight streets, rows of houses kept clean and orderly, and a royal palace so big that he compares it to a whole Dutch town, with galleries whose wooden pillars were covered in cast brass. How much of this should a historian trust?

Start with the source itself. Dapper was a compiler, not a witness, so his picture blends what different traders saw in different decades. He cannot tell us whether the city looked exactly like this in 1668. Next, test it against other evidence. Archaeology confirms a large, planned city with massive earthworks. Surviving brass plaques have nail holes and match his description of brass panels on pillars. Portuguese accounts from a century and a half earlier also describe a big walled town.

The comparison with a Dutch town tells us something too: Dapper's informants were impressed, and they reached for the most familiar measure of size they knew. So a careful reading accepts the broad picture of a great, orderly capital, while treating any exact detail or measurement as possible rather than proven. That habit of testing one kind of evidence against another runs through all of Benin's history.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What do the Edo people call their capital and kingdom?
2. Why did Benin never build armies of horsemen?
3. What was the staple crop of Edo farmers?
4. Who led affairs in Edo villages?
5. Who wrote down palace traditions in A Short History of Benin?
6. Why are early dates in the Benin king list uncertain?
7. What did Graham Connah do in the 1960s?
8. Why must Olfert Dapper's account be read with care?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia